Market cap $2.04 T −7.05 % over 24 hours24h volume $147.89 BBTC dominance 57.5 %ETH 9.9 %Fear & Greed 12 Extreme fearCoins 21,332

43 states and DC tell the CFTC to withdraw its prediction markets rule, and New York seeks a court order against Kalshi

43 states and DC ask the CFTC to withdraw its prediction markets swap rule, while New York seeks a court order against Kalshi after a federal remand.

10 min read

Abstract bank building and flag facing a smartphone, ballot box and warning sign
Table of contents
  1. What 43 states and DC told the CFTC about its prediction markets rules
    1. The quorum argument: one commissioner is not a commission
    2. Who signed and who did not
  2. Kalshi’s New York case returns to state court
  3. New York’s proposed order and Kalshi’s shutdown argument
  4. What changes for people who trade on Kalshi
  5. Dates to watch

The attorneys general of 43 states and the District of Columbia filed two comment letters with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) on Wednesday 18 November against the CFTC prediction markets rules published in October. They ask the agency to withdraw a proposal that would class sports, election and other event contracts as swaps under federal oversight, and they contest a companion rule already in force. A day later, on Thursday 19 November, a federal judge in Manhattan sent New York’s lawsuit against Kalshi back to state court, where the state has proposed a temporary restraining order against the exchange’s contracts. A hearing is set for Monday 23 November, ABC News reported.

Both moves strike at the policy of CFTC chairman Michael Selig, whose agency says event contracts are swaps, a kind of derivative that falls under its jurisdiction. The states call them bets. They also argue that Selig, the only commissioner in office, cannot write rules on his own.

What 43 states and DC told the CFTC about its prediction markets rules

The first letter, sent on the letterhead of Ohio attorney general Andy Wilson to CFTC secretary Christopher Kirkpatrick, answers a proposal titled “Further Definition of ‘blockchain, where users swap tokens directly from their own wallets without handing custody of their funds to a company.">Swap’-Inclusions”. The Federal Register published it on 19 October. It would write into the legal definition of a swap all event contracts, “including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural-, and weather-related events”, in the proposal’s words. It is not in force, and its comment period closed on 18 November.

The states want it withdrawn. Their 25-page letter makes four arguments: the Commodity Exchange Act does not give the CFTC this power; the rulemaking has procedural defects; the proposal is arbitrary under administrative law; and the agency’s reading of the statute raises constitutional problems. The letter ends by saying the CFTC “should start afresh with its rulemaking” and state that sports event contracts are not swaps.

One footnote matters for election markets. The letter concentrates on sports, and says only that “several of the signatories” object to the inclusion of political, election, weather and culture contracts for the same reasons. It does not say how many.

The second letter, on the letterhead of Maryland attorney general Anthony Brown and addressed to Selig, targets a rule that already applies. The interim final rule “Further Definition of ‘Swap’ To Exclude Casino-Style Gambling Products” took effect on 19 October, the day it was published, with comments also due by 18 November. It says that sportsbook wagers and casino games are not swaps.

That sounds like a concession to the states, and the letter accepts the starting point: states have always regulated gambling. What it rejects is the line the rule draws between bets placed against a “house” and bets matched between users. “The IFR rests on a legal fiction,” the states write. Gambling law, they say, has long covered systems where bettors wager against each other, horse racing among them. They add that the agency gave no valid “good cause” for skipping public comment before the rule took effect and did not issue it jointly with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Abstract scales of justice beside a document, a group of people and a flag
Attorneys general of 43 states and DC signed two comment letters to the CFTC on 18 November.
Swap inclusions proposalCasino-style gambling exclusion
TypeNotice of proposed rulemakingInterim final rule
StatusNot in forceIn effect since 19 October 2026
What it doesAdds sports, political, cultural and weather event contracts to the swap definitionSays sportsbook wagers and casino games are not swaps
Federal Register91 FR 66022, 19 October 202691 FR 65969, 19 October 2026
Rule number (RIN)3038-AF823038-AF81
Comments closed18 November 202618 November 2026

The quorum argument: one commissioner is not a commission

Both letters attack the make-up of the CFTC itself. The law provides for five commissioners. Only Selig is in office. The statute says a vacancy “shall not impair the right of the remaining Commissioners to exercise all the powers of the Commission”, and the states read the plural literally.

A single commissioner “does not qualify as ‘Commissioners'”, the swap letter says, and it goes on: “The CFTC needs a quorum of at least two, and perhaps as many as four, commissioners.” On that reading the agency cannot issue any rule, these two included, until the Senate confirms more members.

President Donald Trump sent two names to the Senate on 12 November, Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland. The Senate Agriculture Committee heard both on 17 November, when the CFTC nominees stayed cautious on event contracts. It did not vote.

The swap letter raises a second limit, a geographic one. The Sixth and Ninth Circuit appeals courts have ruled that the Commodity Exchange Act does not hand the CFTC authority over sports event contracts, so the states argue the rule could not take effect in those circuits. The letter also cites the decision of 18 November in which the Fourth Circuit let Maryland police Kalshi’s sports contracts.

Who signed and who did not

Ohio, Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah lead the filing, joined by 35 other states and the District of Columbia. The signature pages of both letters carry no block for seven states: Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota and Texas. The signatories come from both parties. The attorneys general of California and Illinois, both Democrats, signed next to the Republicans of Idaho, Kansas and South Carolina.

Kalshi’s New York case returns to state court

In an opinion and order dated 19 November, US District Judge Vernon Broderick granted New York’s motion to remand its case against KalshiEX LLC (case 26-CV-6550) to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County. Attorney general Letitia James had filed it there on 31 July under Executive Law 63(12), which lets her office bring a special proceeding against a business committing repeated illegal acts. Kalshi moved it to federal court the same day.

The petition asks the court to bar Kalshi permanently from running what the state calls a gambling business without a licence from the New York State Gaming Commission. According to the order’s summary of it, New York alleges that Kalshi lets users aged 18 to 20 trade, when the state sets 21 as the minimum for sports wagering, and that it lists contracts on games involving New York college teams. The state also seeks money: at least $36 billion in disgorgement, restitution and penalties, according to Defirate’s account of the filings.

Broderick did not decide whether the contracts are gambling. He ruled on where the question belongs. Kalshi’s federal licence, he found, is a defence to the state’s claims and not a ground for moving the case. Of the eight causes of action, only one rests on a federal statute, the Wire Act, and the judge found that issue not substantial. He gave the balance between state and federal courts as an independent reason, quoting a 1992 decision: “The scope of laws regulating gambling and lotteries is clearly a matter of predominantly state concern.”

Kalshi escaped one thing. The judge refused New York’s request for legal fees, writing that he could not conclude the company “lacked an objectively reasonable basis for seeking removal”. He left undecided Kalshi’s request to shield itself from an investigative subpoena of the attorney general, since he no longer had jurisdiction, and told the clerk to “effect immediate remand”.

New York’s proposed order and Kalshi’s shutdown argument

Kalshi reacted within hours. On Thursday night its lawyers at Milbank wrote to Justice Melissa Crane, the state judge in Manhattan, Defirate and crypto.news reported on 20 November. She had denied New York’s first injunction request as moot on 3 August, after the case left her court, according to Defirate. The letter asks for a status conference and for a chance to respond before any order is signed.

The dispute is over a few words. The order New York proposed would bar contracts on “sports, culture, elections, and other events” made “within or from New York or to persons in New York”, in the wording both outlets quote. Kalshi is based in New York. By their account, its lawyers argue that “from New York” could therefore reach customers in every state, and that the undefined “other events” could take in contracts on financial and economic data.

That nationwide reading is Kalshi’s argument, and the CFTC made the same one in court on Friday. No court has adopted it. ABC News describes the suit differently: it does not seek to shut Kalshi down, though it could force changes to how the company operates, and the order requested would stop Kalshi offering sports contracts without a state licence.

On Friday 20 November the CFTC stepped in. In the separate federal case United States v. State of New York (1:26-cv-03404), the docket shows a renewed emergency motion by the agency for a restraining order, with the “Proposed Temporary Restraining Order Filed by New York in State Court” attached as an exhibit. Judge Lorna Schofield called a telephone conference for 5 p.m. in New York (22:00 UTC) the same day.

She turned the agency down, according to ABC News, and declined to stop Justice Crane from ruling. “The requested application is denied,” the judge said, in ABC’s account of the call, which quotes both sides. “The temporary restraining order New York seeks would completely shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide,” CFTC attorney Andrew Weisberg said. Kate Rhodes Janofsky, for the attorney general’s office, answered: “They have to put in evidence of irreparable harm. They have not done so.”

Abstract gavel over a city skyline with an hourglass and a padlock
New York's proposed order against Kalshi now sits with a state judge in Manhattan.

The exchange is already under a federal instruction that points the other way. On 11 August the CFTC used its emergency powers to order Kalshi to keep operating, calling New York’s action a “major market disturbance”, Defirate recalls. A state order to stop would leave Kalshi facing two opposite commands.

No ruling by Justice Crane on the restraining order had been reported by 06:20 UTC on Saturday 21 November. At that time the federal docket on CourtListener showed no written order after the entry of 20 November scheduling the call.

What changes for people who trade on Kalshi

Nothing yet. No ruling on New York’s order has been reported, the proposed swap rule is still a proposal, and the Federal Register notice sets no date for a final version. The states’ letters are comments, which the agency must consider but does not have to follow.

Other states are not waiting for the rule. Louisiana went to court on 13 November and won a same-day order against four platforms’ event contracts, and the CFTC sued the state in return. Earlier in the month the CFTC gave prediction markets 30 days to unblock states that courts had told them to block. Separately, the Senate has passed a bill that would ban prediction-market bets on war, terrorism and death, Decrypt reported on 20 November.

For readers new to the subject: an event contract pays a fixed amount if a stated outcome happens and nothing if it does not, and its price moves between the two as traders buy and sell. The legal fight is over the label. If the contract is a swap, the CFTC regulates it nationwide. If it is a wager, each state decides. Our guide explains how prediction markets work and where the law stands.

Dates to watch

  • Monday 23 November: hearing before Justice Crane on New York’s restraining order request, according to ABC News.
  • 7 December: Kalshi’s response to New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition in its own case against the exchange is due, per Defirate.
  • No date: Judge Schofield’s ruling on the federal government’s motion for a preliminary injunction against New York, still pending on the docket, and the Senate committee vote on the two CFTC nominees.

Sources

  1. Comment letter of 43 states and DC on the CFTC swap inclusions proposal, 18 November 2026 (PDF) nj.gov
  2. Comment letter of 43 states and DC on the CFTC casino-style gambling interim final rule, 18 November 2026 (PDF) nj.gov
  3. Federal Register: Further Definition of "Swap"-Inclusions, 19 October 2026 federalregister.gov
  4. SDNY opinion and order remanding New York v. KalshiEX, 19 November 2026 (PDF) storage.courtlistener.com
  5. ABC News: administration tries to intervene after Kalshi is threatened with restraining order, 20 November 2026 abcnews.com
  6. Defirate: Kalshi's New York case goes back to state court, 20 November 2026 defirate.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *