President Donald Trump’s two nominees for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland, spent more than an hour in front of the Senate Agriculture Committee on Tuesday 17 November, and most of it went to prediction markets. Neither took a strong stand against the agency’s current line on event contracts, CoinDesk reported that evening. The committee did not vote, and no vote is on its calendar.
The hearing for the CFTC nominees opened at 3 p.m. Eastern (20:00 UTC) in room 106 of the Dirksen building, according to Bitcoin Magazine’s preview of 16 November. Both men work for the committee that was questioning them: Anonick on the Republican staff of chairman John Boozman, Rowland as a CFTC attorney on loan to the Democratic staff of ranking member Amy Klobuchar. CoinDesk describes a cordial session in which most of the senators present were Democrats.
The White House sent the two names to the Senate on 12 November. The session ends in early January, and nominations not confirmed by then normally go back to the president.
What the CFTC nominees said about event contracts
Rowland went furthest. He told senators that federal law directs the CFTC to weigh the public interest when it looks at certain event contracts, and that the agency should “think long and hard about balancing the public interest” against how economically useful those contracts are, in CoinDesk’s account. He said he hopes to work on the prediction-markets rulemaking the commission has opened, and that he expects a Supreme Court decision “within the next term or the one after”, in the words CDC Gaming quotes. CDC Gaming, a gambling trade outlet, dates the proposal to 9 October: a rule that would define “blockchain, where users swap tokens directly from their own wallets without handing custody of their funds to a company.">swap” so that it covers event contracts.
According to The Block, Rowland also cited Regulation 40.11, a CFTC rule from 2011 that bars registered exchanges from listing or clearing event contracts involving gaming, terrorism, war or assassination. Whether a contract on a football game counts as “gaming” under that rule is what the courts are being asked. He said it was hard for him to comment on the agency’s lawsuits, called himself “certainly very sympathetic” to the concerns of states and tribes, and said he would want to work with them if confirmed.
Anonick gave less away. He called the question legally complex because federal courts have disagreed, and said the commission has discretion to find that a contract involving gaming is against the public interest. Both nominees said they would be bound by a Supreme Court ruling on the matter, CDC Gaming reports.
“It’s a very charged, emotional issue, and I appreciate how sensitive it is,” Anonick said, as quoted by CoinDesk.
An event contract pays out according to whether something happens: a rate cut, an election result, the score of a football game. Exchanges such as Kalshi list them as federally regulated derivatives, which is why the CFTC claims them and why state gambling regulators object. Our guide to how prediction markets work and where the law stands explains the mechanics.
Smith, Schiff and Klobuchar press on sports betting
The word “emotional” did not go down well with Tina Smith, the Minnesota Democrat. “I think this is a legal issue,” she answered, in the words both CoinDesk and The Block report. The Block also quotes her saying the law is “quite clear” that jurisdiction over sports gambling lies with states and tribes.
Smith had her own state in mind. Minnesota passed a ban on prediction markets in May and a federal judge has temporarily blocked it. Smith told the nominees that Chairman Michael Selig’s CFTC has sued Minnesota and 11 other states, according to CDC Gaming, the only outlet to give that count; The Block speaks of nearly a dozen states and the CFTC suing each other. One of the states Smith listed is Arkansas, home of the committee’s chairman. She walked both nominees through two points of law, and both agreed with her on each: that the Supreme Court’s 2018 decision striking down the federal sports betting ban returned that power to the states, and that the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act gives tribes authority over gaming on their land. Her conclusion, in CDC Gaming’s account, was that a contract that works like a bet is a bet. Rowland answered that courts have ruled both ways.
Adam Schiff of California put to both men the question he had asked Selig at his own confirmation hearing: is an event contract on one NFL game, Colts against Texans, the same thing as a sports bet? Anonick would not say. “I just say it’s legally complex,” he replied, as quoted by CDC Gaming, which adds that Schiff voiced concern that Anonick would follow Selig’s view that these contracts belong to the federal regulator.
Klobuchar reminded Rowland, who works for her, that the CFTC argues in court that state law is preempted. She asked what duty the agency has to check on its own whether a contract falls under the statutory bans or breaks state, tribal or federal law. Rowland replied that the Commodity Exchange Act’s special rule on event contracts does direct the agency to think about the public interest.
One of the latest of those cases is the subject of our report on Louisiana’s lawsuit against Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood and Coinbase, which the CFTC answered with a suit of its own.
A commission of one, and about a quarter fewer staff
The CFTC has five seats, of which no more than three may go to one party. Only one is filled. Selig, sworn in on 22 December 2025, is the sole sitting commissioner, so commission decisions are his alone, from the interpretation telling prediction markets to stop geoblocking states to the approval of Backpack’s US derivatives exchange on 17 November.

| Seat | Party | Position | Term ends |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Selig, chairman (sitting) | Republican | Sworn in 22 December 2025 | 13 April 2029 |
| Nathan Anonick, of Virginia (nominee) | Republican | Senior counsel on the Agriculture Committee’s Republican staff | 19 June 2031 |
| Matthew Rowland, of the District of Columbia (nominee) | Democrat | CFTC attorney detailed to the committee’s Democratic staff | 13 April 2028 |
| Two further seats | Vacant | No nominee | Not applicable |
Anonick is nominated to the seat once held by former chairman Rostin Behnam, Rowland to finish the term of Summer Mersinger; the term dates are those given by Bitcoin Magazine and CDC Gaming. Selig’s own term as commissioner runs to 13 April 2029, according to the White House’s nomination notice of October 2025. Even with both nominees confirmed, two seats would stay empty. Rowland and Kristin Johnson, Trump’s Democratic pick for the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), are the first Democrats he has nominated to either agency since returning to office, according to a Bloomberg report carried by Insurance Journal.
The agency underneath has shrunk too. One of the senators noted that the CFTC has lost about a quarter of its staff under Selig, during the administration’s cuts to the federal workforce, CoinDesk reports without naming the senator or giving a headcount. Both nominees said they were open to hiring as the workload requires, and both backed filling the empty seats. Anonick’s phrase, in CoinDesk: “a full commission is the best approach to sound, durable policy.”
Warnock asks whether ties to the president matter
Raphael Warnock, the Georgia Democrat, took the hearing somewhere less comfortable. He asked whether a company’s links to the president or his family should ever affect how the CFTC treats it, raised the involvement of Donald Trump Jr. in the prediction-markets industry, and cited reports that the agency’s political leadership had stopped senior career officials from examining firms with Trump family business dealings. CoinDesk, which relays the exchange, links those reports to a New York Times article.
“I think that the law needs to be enforced fairly without fear or favor, and so the answer is no,” Rowland replied, as quoted by CoinDesk. Anonick agreed that the law should apply equally to everyone. “It should not matter who is involved,” he said.
Spot crypto barely appears in accounts of the hearing
The accounts of the hearing by CoinDesk, The Block and CDC Gaming centre on prediction markets. None describes a question on the agency’s authority over spot trading in tokens.
Both witnesses know the subject. Anonick helped lead the Agriculture Committee’s part of the Clarity Act, the market structure bill that would divide oversight of digital assets between the SEC and the CFTC, according to Bloomberg, and Rowland worked on the same text, as we noted in our piece on the four SEC and CFTC nominations. The bill failed a Senate cloture vote by 49 to 50 on 15 September, and it dies when this Congress ends on 3 January unless the lame-duck session revives it, Bitcoin Magazine wrote on 16 November.
Without a law, the CFTC has set crypto policy on its own this year. Bitcoin Magazine cites its opening to funding payment between longs and shorts, settled every few hours, keeps the contract price close to the spot or index price.">perpetual futures on stocks, which a federal judge said probably exceeded the agency’s powers while letting trading continue.
Nine Democrats’ letter on geoblocks and Politico’s reported probes
Two of the senators who questioned the nominees had written to Selig the day before. On Monday 16 November, nine Senate Democrats led by Schiff asked him to withdraw the 5 November geoblock interpretation, a letter we first reported in our piece on the CFTC’s stay of Kalshi’s Trump mention contracts. Bitcoin.com News, citing Schiff’s office, has since given more of its content.
The signatories are every senator from California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington, plus Klobuchar; Bitcoin.com News names only Schiff and Klobuchar. If the CFTC will not withdraw or freeze the interpretation until the lawsuits end, they want it at least to state that a geoblock does not breach its rule in three cases: when a court ordered it, when it follows federal Indian gaming law or a tribal-state compact, and when an exchange adds it by choice. They also ask the agency to preserve all related records back to 1 January 2025, and they want an answer by 23 November.
The letter’s language is sharp. The commission “now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders”, the senators write, as quoted by Bitcoin.com News, and the timing of the interpretation, hours after a California federal court ordered Kalshi to geofence tribal land, “raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation.” Bitcoin.com News reports no reply from the CFTC.
The same day, Politico reported that the CFTC is running separate investigations of Kalshi and Polymarket, and has been for months, according to Bitcoin.com News, whose summary names no source for Politico’s account. The CFTC has not confirmed either investigation. On Kalshi, the agency is said to be examining whether the exchange properly notified it of dozens of new products, the subject of the warning of possible charges that Politico first reported on 10 November. On Polymarket, the inquiry is described as broad and tied in part to the company’s 2022 settlement with the CFTC, which required it to close its platform to US users. No charges or enforcement action have been announced against either company.
In a statement to Politico that confirms no inquiry, CFTC spokesperson Zach Fulton said the agency’s enforcement work “knows no bounds” and added: “We will pursue misconduct wherever it occurs.” Kalshi’s head of federal government relations, John Bivona, said the agency was “doing their job”; on 10 November a Kalshi spokesperson had said the warning was about “a procedural error involving the submission of a handful of contracts”. A Polymarket spokesperson said the company works “with regulators and law enforcement to protect the quality and integrity of our markets.”

Frank Lucas, an Oklahoma Republican on the House Agriculture Committee, told Politico that once the new Congress starts in January “nobody’s untouchable anymore”, in the passage Bitcoin.com News quotes.
No committee vote, and a Senate that changes hands in January
Boozman closed the hearing by saying the record would stay open for two business days, CDC Gaming reports. After that, each nominee needs a vote in committee and then a confirmation vote of the full Senate. Timing is tight before the new Congress convenes in January, The Block notes, and nominations left unconfirmed generally have to be submitted again. Democrats won both chambers in the 3 November midterms and take control then.
Forecasts differ. CoinDesk writes that the pair are widely expected to be confirmed before the session ends. Jaret Seiberg, the policy analyst at TD Cowen, told clients before the hearing that he does not expect Democrats to confirm Trump’s nominees unless the president fills Democratic seats at agencies such as the FDIC and the SEC, which he considers unlikely, according to Bitcoin Magazine.
| Date | What is due |
|---|---|
| Thursday 19 November | Senate Banking Committee hears SEC nominees Steven Levine and Kristin Johnson, 10 a.m. Eastern |
| Monday 23 November | Reply requested from the CFTC to the nine senators’ geoblock letter |
| Not scheduled | Agriculture Committee vote on Anonick and Rowland, then a Senate floor vote |
| 3 January 2027 | The Clarity Act lapses unless it is revived (Bitcoin Magazine); unconfirmed nominations are normally returned around the start of the new Congress |
