Market cap $2.19 T −3.65 % over 24 hours24h volume $73.68 BBTC dominance 58.1 %ETH 10.0 %Fear & Greed 10 Extreme fearCoins 21,490

Fourth Circuit rules 2-1 that Maryland can police Kalshi’s sports contracts, and the three judges give three different reasons

The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on 18 November that Maryland can enforce its betting laws on Kalshi's sports contracts. The judges split three ways.

12 min read

Abstract gavel and scales of justice beside a flag and a smartphone
Table of contents
  1. What the Fourth Circuit decided in Kalshi’s appeal
  2. Three judges, three reasons
    1. Gregory: even if these are swaps, Maryland keeps its authority
    2. Thacker: the outcome of a game is not an “event”
    3. Benjamin, dissenting: swaps, and the CFTC’s field
  3. Who lined up on each side
  4. Four appeals courts, three for the states
  5. What the ruling reaches, and what it does not
  6. Next dates: the rehearing window and the Supreme Court petition
  7. Why the word “swap” carries so much weight

Kalshi lost its appeal against Maryland on Wednesday 18 November. A three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in Richmond, voted 2-1 to uphold a lower court’s refusal to shield the prediction market from the state’s sports wagering laws, in a published opinion in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin (No. 25-1892). Maryland may therefore keep treating Kalshi’s sports event contracts as sports betting that needs a state licence while the case continues.

The court’s own text is a single sentence: the judgment of the district court is affirmed. Everything else in the 59-page document is three separate opinions that disagree with each other. There is no majority reasoning. Judge Roger Gregory says the state wins whether or not the contracts are swaps under federal law. Judge Stephanie Thacker says they are not swaps at all. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin, in dissent, says they are swaps and that Maryland has no say over them.

That makes four federal appeals courts that have ruled on Kalshi’s sports contracts in 2026, three of them for the states. It also means two judges who reached the same result in Richmond could not agree on the question the Supreme Court is being asked to settle.

What the Fourth Circuit decided in Kalshi’s appeal

The appeal was about a preliminary injunction, not the final outcome of the lawsuit. Judge Gregory’s opinion gives the sequence. On 7 April 2025 the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission and its agency sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter saying the company was offering “wagering on sporting events” to Marylanders without the state licence required, and gave it fifteen days to stop. Kalshi sued on 21 April 2025, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) hands its exchange to one regulator only, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and asked for an order barring Maryland from enforcing its law.

District Judge Adam Abelson, in Baltimore, refused on 1 August 2025. He assumed for the sake of argument that the contracts were swaps and still found that Congress had not clearly meant to take gambling regulation away from the states. Kalshi appealed, the Fourth Circuit heard the case on 7 May 2026, and the ruling came a little more than six months later.

What Maryland asks of a sports wagering operator is set out in Judge Gregory’s opinion: a state licence before taking wagers from people located in Maryland, data security obligations, no deceptive advertising and no advertising aimed at people barred from betting or at risk. The state does not claim the power to decide which contracts a federal exchange may list.

Kalshi is a designated contract market (DCM), the CFTC’s category for a regulated derivatives exchange. Its users trade against each other and not against the house, a difference with FanDuel or DraftKings that Gregory spells out. The same paragraph then notes that Kalshi advertises itself as “the first app for legal sports betting in all 50 states”.

Three judges, three reasons

Gregory: even if these are swaps, Maryland keeps its authority

The first concurrence calls its conclusion “a narrow one”. Judge Gregory writes: “I do not decide whether Kalshi’s sports event contracts are ‘swaps’ within the meaning of the CEA.” His point is that the blockchain, where users swap tokens directly from their own wallets without handing custody of their funds to a company.">swap label settles whether the CFTC can regulate the contracts, not whether the states are shut out.

He rests that on a part of the same statute known as the Special Rule, which lets the CFTC find that event contracts involving gaming are contrary to the public interest and keep them off regulated exchanges, and on the agency’s Rule 40.11, which says an exchange “shall not list” contracts that involve gaming. Kalshi’s sports contracts trade, he notes, because Kalshi certified on its own that they comply and the CFTC has issued no final decision either way. A self-certified contract “reflects only the exchange’s legal position”.

The agency itself has not made things clearer, in his reading. In 2023 the CFTC prohibited Kalshi’s contracts on control of Congress after concluding that they involved gaming. In March 2026 it asked for public comment on what “gaming” means, and in June 2026 it proposed amendments to Rule 40.11 that are still pending. With the statute and the regulator both unsettled, Gregory applies the presumption that Congress does not override traditional state powers without saying so plainly: “Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so.”

He also rejects the argument that the two regimes cannot coexist. Kalshi can take a Maryland licence or stop offering those contracts in the state, he writes, adding that it “cannot manufacture a conflict by choosing not to comply” with one of the two.

Thacker: the outcome of a game is not an “event”

Judge Thacker concurs only in the result and takes the question Gregory avoids. The CEA defines a swap as a contract whose payment depends on “the occurrence, nonoccurrence, or the extent of the occurrence of an event or contingency” tied to a potential financial, economic or commercial consequence. For her, the event in sport is the match itself. A contract that pays if a prize fight does not take place, or if it lasts less than three rounds, turns on whether or how far the event occurred. A contract on who wins turns on its outcome, and “the outcome of an event is not the occurrence of the event”.

She adds an argument from consequences. Congress put swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction with the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010. If Kalshi’s contracts met the definition, she writes, so would nearly every sports bet in America, and nearly every bet placed off an exchange over “the better part of the past two decades” would have been illegal. Her verdict on Kalshi’s product is blunt: “What is happening here is sports betting.” And, a few lines on: “That is gambling, plain and simple.”

Thacker also cites the oral argument, where Kalshi’s counsel said: “I don’t dispute that a year ago we did advertise as sports betting.”

Benjamin, dissenting: swaps, and the CFTC’s field

Judge Benjamin would have vacated the district court’s order and sent the case back to weigh the remaining injunction factors. She finds it “hard to agree” that a team winning a game is not the occurrence of an event, and warns that Thacker’s line invites word games: an exchange could relabel a contract on the Buffalo Bills winning the Super Bowl as one on a victory parade being held in Buffalo.

Her opinion accepts that a limit is needed, or office pools and casino games would all become swaps. She draws it at contracts tied to a real economic consequence, the kind a sponsor, a ticket reseller or a bar near a stadium could use to hedge: individual game results and season outcomes would qualify, while parlays and proposition bets would not.

Once the contracts are swaps, the statute’s grant of “exclusive jurisdiction” to the CFTC over swaps traded on a DCM ends the matter for her. She concedes the common objection that Kalshi looks like a casino “appears logical”, then answers: “But that’s not what Congress said.” Her closing line on the state’s role: “Just because the CFTC hasn’t disapproved Kalshi’s sports-related contracts under its regulations, doesn’t mean Maryland can regulate Kalshi in its place.”

Abstract gavel beside a group of figures, a document and a signed contract
Two judges upheld Maryland's position for different reasons and the third dissented.

Who lined up on each side

The list of friends of the court shows how wide the dispute has become. Nevada, Ohio, 36 other states and the District of Columbia filed in support of Maryland, alongside the American Gaming Association, tribal gaming associations and the advocacy group Better Markets. Two parties backed Kalshi: the crypto investment firm Paradigm and the fantasy sports company Underdog. The CFTC is listed in the opinion neither as a party nor as a friend of the court.

Reactions followed the split. A Kalshi spokesperson told CBS Baltimore: “Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong.” The company said the three contradictory opinions show there is no unified legal argument against prediction markets. Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown, quoted by the same outlet, said betting platforms that operate outside state oversight leave Marylanders without the protections that keep gambling fair and safe, and that his office will keep defending them.

Baltimore’s own consumer-protection lawsuit against Kalshi and Polymarket, filed in August, continues separately, CBS Baltimore reports.

Four appeals courts, three for the states

The courts of appeals, Judge Gregory writes, “have reached no consensus”. The Third Circuit sided with Kalshi against New Jersey on 6 April 2026, with Judge Jane Roth dissenting, holding that the sports contracts are swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. The Ninth Circuit went the other way for Nevada on 28 August 2026, finding the contracts are likely not swaps. The Sixth Circuit followed on 25 September 2026 in a case from Ohio: Gregory summarises it as finding that the contracts are not swaps and that Kalshi failed to show Congress meant to preempt state sports gambling laws. That panel was unanimous and its ruling covers Ohio and Tennessee, according to Al Jazeera’s report of that decision.

CourtStateDateResult
Third CircuitNew Jersey6 April 2026For Kalshi (2-1): the contracts are swaps, state law is preempted
Ninth CircuitNevada28 August 2026For the state: the contracts are likely not swaps
Sixth CircuitOhio, Tennessee25 September 2026For the states: the contracts are not swaps
Fourth CircuitMaryland18 November 2026For the state (2-1), with no shared reasoning

The reasoning is as divided as the results. The Ninth Circuit, the Sixth Circuit and Judge Thacker say the contracts are not swaps, or likely not. The Third Circuit and Judge Benjamin say they are, and that this shuts the states out. Judge Gregory, like Judge Roth in her Third Circuit dissent, says the label does not matter because Congress never clearly displaced state gambling law. Benjamin points out that even the Ninth Circuit read the exclusive-jurisdiction clause as preemptive for contracts that do qualify as swaps.

Trial courts are no closer. Gregory’s opinion lists five district court rulings that found no preemption (Nevada, Ohio, New York, Utah and, in a suit brought by another prediction market, Michigan) and four that found for Kalshi or the federal government (New Jersey, Arizona, Tennessee and Minnesota). Several have since gone up to the appeals courts.

What the ruling reaches, and what it does not

The judgment binds Kalshi and the Maryland officials it sued. It leaves in place a 2025 order denying a preliminary injunction; it does not close the underlying lawsuit, and it does not order Kalshi to do anything. What it removes is the prospect of a federal court order stopping Maryland from enforcing its sports wagering law against the company.

The Fourth Circuit hears appeals from federal courts in Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina and South Carolina. The opinion is published, but the part that speaks for the court is one sentence, and the two judges in the majority gave different grounds. What weight federal courts in the other four states will give it is an open question.

Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase and Crypto.com are not parties, and none of the three opinions names them. The appeal concerned Kalshi’s sports event contracts only; contracts on elections, economic data or crypto prices were not before the court.

Those companies face the states in other courtrooms. Louisiana has sued Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood and Coinbase, and the CFTC sued the state in return. Crypto.com and Novig went to court against Missouri over sports event contracts in October. The CFTC, for its part, has given exchanges 30 days to reopen states that courts had ordered them to block. Kalshi is the only platform quoted in CBS Baltimore’s report on the ruling.

Abstract flag and shield next to a warning sign and a globe
The judgment covers Kalshi and Maryland, while other platforms face the states in separate cases.

Next dates: the rehearing window and the Supreme Court petition

Kalshi can ask the panel or the full Fourth Circuit to rehear the case. Rule 40 of the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure allows 14 days from the entry of judgment in a case where the federal government is not a party; counted from the 18 November date on the opinion, that is 2 December. The prediction-markets newsletter The PM Pulse, which dates the ruling to 17 November, gives 1 December. Kalshi’s statement to CBS Baltimore does not mention a next step.

The larger calendar is in Washington. New Jersey asked the Supreme Court on 2 September 2026 to review the Third Circuit ruling, the only appellate win Kalshi has. The Supreme Court docket for case No. 26-299 shows Kalshi’s response, already postponed twice, is now due on 7 December 2026. Friend-of-the-court briefs have come in from Ohio and other states, the National Football League, 145 tribes, the American Gaming Association and former CFTC chairman Gary Gensler, among others. The docket shows no conference date and no decision on whether the justices will take the case.

More appellate rulings are on the way. Appeals are pending in the Second, Seventh and Tenth Circuits, The PM Pulse reports. In Maryland, the case returns to Judge Abelson’s court, where the merits have yet to be decided.

Why the word “swap” carries so much weight

A sports event contract on Kalshi is a yes-or-no instrument that pays out if the stated result happens. Kalshi lists such contracts by certifying to the CFTC that they comply with federal law. If they are swaps traded on a designated contract market, the CEA gives the CFTC “exclusive jurisdiction” over them, and Kalshi’s case is that this leaves no room for 50 state gambling regulators.

The states answer that a bet does not stop being a bet because it is packaged as a derivative, and that sports wagering is theirs to license. Our guide explains how prediction markets work and where the law stands on Polymarket and Kalshi.

Sources

  1. US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892, published opinion of 18 November 2026 ca4.uscourts.gov
  2. US Supreme Court docket, No. 26-299, Flaherty v. KalshiEX LLC supremecourt.gov
  3. CBS Baltimore, report on the Fourth Circuit ruling with statements from Kalshi and Maryland's attorney general, 18 November 2026 cbsnews.com
  4. The PM Pulse 091, 18 November 2026 pmpulse.substack.com
  5. Al Jazeera, report on the Sixth Circuit ruling for Ohio and Tennessee, 25 September 2026 aljazeera.com
  6. Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure, Rule 40 (panel rehearing and rehearing en banc), Legal Information Institute law.cornell.edu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *