Market cap $2.04 T −7.05 % over 24 hours24h volume $147.89 BBTC dominance 57.5 %ETH 9.9 %Fear & Greed 12 Extreme fearCoins 21,332

SEC nominees split on tokenized stocks at their Senate hearing: Johnson wants a full rule, Levine defends the exemption

At the 19 November hearing, Kristin Johnson backed a notice-and-comment rule for the SEC's tokenized-stock exemption. Steven Levine called it narrow.

9 min read

Abstract bank building behind a shield and a network of connected nodes
Table of contents
  1. Johnson asks for notice and comment, Levine cites the ETF precedent
  2. What the SEC innovation exemption allows
  3. Warren pressed both nominees on private credit and SEC enforcement
  4. Two of five SEC seats are filled, and no vote is set

The two people nominated to fill empty seats at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) gave different answers on tokenized stocks at their Senate confirmation hearing on Thursday 19 November 2026. Kristin Johnson, the Democrat, told the Senate Banking Committee she would welcome a formal rulemaking, with a public comment period, on the SEC’s “innovation exemption” for onchain trading of US shares, according to CoinDesk and Cointelegraph. Steven Levine, the Republican, described the exemption as time-limited and narrow, CoinDesk reported, and compared it to the way exchange-traded funds started.

In the published accounts, that was the main crypto exchange of the morning. The session opened at 10:00 ET in the Dirksen building and covered five nominees, according to the committee’s hearing page, which lists no committee vote on the two. Elizabeth Warren, the ranking Democrat on a committee chaired by Republican Tim Scott, used her time on private credit and on the fall in SEC enforcement.

Who the two nominees are, which seats they would take and until when is in our piece on the announcement of the SEC nominations and the hearing date.

Johnson asks for notice and comment, Levine cites the ETF precedent

Johnson was answering Senator Angela Alsobrooks, a Maryland Democrat, Cointelegraph reported. “I feel strongly that regulation is made better through the notice-and-comment period,” she said, in the words printed by CoinDesk. She would “welcome the opportunity” to take the subject into a formal rulemaking, “especially when the stakeholders we see raising concerns are in fact market participants, registrants themselves”, the outlet quoted her as saying.

Cointelegraph adds that Johnson raised anti-money-laundering and know-your-customer compliance, and said the objections to the exemption go beyond investor protection.

Levine, according to Cointelegraph, said he had not studied the exemption closely and understood it to be limited in time and to carry investor protections. He added that Congress gave the SEC the power to grant exemptions that serve the public interest, the outlet reported. CoinDesk, which sums up his description as time-limited and narrow without printing those words as a quote, does quote him on the history: “many innovations, such as the exchange traded fund, began as a series of exemptive orders” that, he went on, “ultimately resulted in agency rulemaking”.

The written statements the two filed with the committee, posted on the hearing page, point the same way without naming the exemption. Johnson wrote: “Artificial intelligence, tokenization, stablecoins, and decentralized platforms promise lower costs and wider access”, and added that they also raise questions about conflicts of interest, data governance and accountability. One sentence is about crypto alone: “In digital asset markets, I have focused on strong governance, conflicts of interest rules, and segregation of customer assets.”

Levine’s statement does not contain the words tokenization, crypto or digital assets. He wrote that US capital markets are “in the midst of transformative innovation” and that the SEC has handled such changes before, giving exchange-traded funds and money market funds as examples of products that were once new. On his own career, the statement says he joined the SEC staff and has spent the past two years as “a detailee to the Council of Economic Advisers and the Department of Labor”.

Abstract scales of justice beside a document, a gavel and a megaphone
Johnson asked for a rule with public comment; Levine pointed to exemptive orders as a first stage.

What the SEC innovation exemption allows

The text they were asked about is an order the SEC issued on 17 September 2026 and announced in press release 2026-90. It exempts what the agency calls blockchain tokens that record a claim on an asset held off chain, such as Treasury bills, fund shares, loans or gold. A custodian keeps the asset, a transfer agent keeps the register, and the token is worth what that structure lets its holder claim.">Tokenized Securities Venues from the legal definition of an exchange, so that they can trade tokenized versions of US-listed shares through permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools. A second exemption, from the definition of a dealer, covers certain firms that supply liquidity to those pools with their own capital. Both are set to expire five years after publication.

The relief comes with conditions. The token must give holders the same rights as the ordinary share. The smart contracts must be public and auditable, and sit on a public, permissionless ledger. Trading on the venue must stop whenever the share is halted on its main exchange. The order (Exchange Act Release 34-106402) also caps activity: for the stocks in Tier 1 of the market’s limit up-limit down plan, a venue may trade at most 75 symbols and 0.25% of each stock’s average daily share volume of the previous month; for Tier 2 stocks, 250 symbols and 2.5%.

One condition explains much of the current dispute. Before a venue lists a token created by a third party unrelated to the company, it must notify the company in writing, and the company has 30 calendar days to object. If it does, the order says, the token cannot be made available on that venue.

Companies have used that right. Cointelegraph, citing a public notice dated 5 November, reports that 67 listed companies opposed the tokenization of their shares on the OKXICE platform; CoinDesk writes of dozens. Four senators have separately asked the agency who checks for money laundering on these venues, a letter covered in our piece on the senators’ questions to the SEC about tokenized stocks.

The order itself does not rule out what Johnson asked for. Its text says the Commission “may determine to undertake rulemaking in the future”, calls the exemptions “time-limited”, the word CoinDesk attributes to Levine, and asks for public comment on possible changes “as an initial step in that process”. In the release, Chairman Paul Atkins invites comment “on all aspects” of the exemption. So the order sets a sequence: relief granted first, comment invited afterwards, a rule possible later. In a notice-and-comment rulemaking the order is reversed, with a proposal published and comments taken before anything is adopted. For readers new to the product, our guide explains what tokenized stocks are and what the holder really owns.

Warren pressed both nominees on private credit and SEC enforcement

Warren, listed as ranking member on the committee’s membership page, did not mention crypto in her opening statement. She told Levine she doubted he would be anything other than “just another puppet who will put Wall Street profits over protecting American investors”, citing his time at the Labor Department and the White House. To Johnson she said: “President Trump has kept Democrats off the SEC for nearly a year, and even now, he’s refusing to fill the second Democratic seat.”

In questioning, Warren asked the SEC and Treasury nominees whether private credit could pose a serious risk to the financial system. The answers, from the transcript her office published, separated the two SEC candidates again. Levine: “I have seen no evidence that private credit currently poses a systemic risk.” Johnson: “I am a systemic risk scholar, and I believe there is the potential for systemic risk concerns related to the market that you identified.”

Asked about the SEC’s enforcement record for fiscal 2026, Levine said the results “are lower in total than in previous years”. Warren then gave her own figures: overall enforcement down 40%, actions against public companies down 80%, money ordered returned to investors down almost 90%. Those percentages are hers; the transcript gives no source for them.

One more crypto-adjacent subject came up. Senator Catherine Cortez Masto, a Democrat, accused prediction-market firms of trading security-based swaps in the form of equity-based perpetual contracts, according to CoinDesk. Johnson replied that there are “very critical and important questions” about which agency has jurisdiction; Levine took no position, the outlet reported. The same line between the SEC and the CFTC ran through the CFTC nominees’ hearing the day before.

SubjectKristin Johnson (Democrat)Steven Levine (Republican)Source
Formal rule for the tokenized-stock exemptionWould welcome a notice-and-comment rulemakingTime-limited and narrow, in CoinDesk’s summary; ETFs began as exemptive ordersCoinDesk, Cointelegraph
Private creditSees potential for systemic risk concernsHas seen no evidence of a current systemic riskWarren transcript
Equity-linked perpetuals on prediction marketsSays jurisdiction raises critical questionsTook no positionCoinDesk
Digital assets in the written statementGovernance, conflicts of interest, segregation of customer assetsNot mentioned by nameCommittee hearing page

Two of five SEC seats are filled, and no vote is set

The SEC has five seats and no more than three may go to one party. The agency’s own list of commissioners, last updated on 3 October 2026, shows two names, Chairman Paul Atkins and Commissioner Mark Uyeda. The page does not state their party; both are Republicans. If the Senate confirms Levine and Johnson, the commission would have four members, three Republicans and one Democrat. Warren’s complaint that the president is “refusing to fill the second Democratic seat” refers to the fifth.

On those numbers Johnson would hold one vote in four, not enough to block a tokenization rule or an extension of the exemption on her own. A commissioner in the minority can still dissent in writing and argue for a comment period, the process she backed before the committee. Jessica Martinez, US policy director at Fireblocks, told Cointelegraph: “Crypto isn’t a partisan issue, and the rules that come out of a bipartisan commission will stand on firmer footing.”

Congress, meanwhile, is not writing the rules. With the CLARITY Act given little or no chance this year, the September order is the text that governs onchain trading of US shares for now.

Abstract hourglass and calendar next to a plain flag and a group of people
Two of five SEC seats are filled, and this Congress ends on 3 January 2027.

The next step is on paper. Senators had until noon on Friday 20 November to send written questions, and the nominees must answer by 5:00 pm ET on Tuesday 24 November (22:00 UTC), Cointelegraph reported, citing the closing remarks of the hearing. After that the committee can vote on whether to send the nominations to the full Senate, where a confirmation vote follows. The hearing page lists no date for a committee vote, and no floor date has been announced.

The calendar is tight. Under the Constitution this Congress ends at noon on 3 January 2027, and Thanksgiving falls on Thursday 26 November. Democrats take the Senate majority in January, when Warren is expected to move from ranking member to chair of the committee, CoinDesk notes. Before any of that come the written answers due on 24 November, where senators can press both nominees again on tokenized stocks.

Sources

  1. Senate Banking Committee, nomination hearing of 19 November 2026 (witness statements) banking.senate.gov
  2. SEC press release 2026-90, innovation exemption for tokenized NMS stock, 17 September 2026 sec.gov
  3. SEC order, Exchange Act Release 34-106402, 17 September 2026 sec.gov
  4. Senate Banking Committee minority, transcript of Senator Warren's questioning, 19 November 2026 banking.senate.gov
  5. CoinDesk, Trump's Democratic SEC pick suggests tokenization policy deserves full rule process, 19 November 2026 coindesk.com
  6. Cointelegraph, report on the SEC nominees and tokenized stocks, 19 November 2026 cointelegraph.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *