The CLARITY Act is unlikely to become law this year, by the estimate of the two Republicans most identified with it. Asked on Thursday 19 November 2026 at the Capitol Crypto Forum in Washington what could realistically be done in the weeks Congress has left, Senator Bernie Moreno of Ohio answered: “Zero. Zero.” Representative French Hill of Arkansas, who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, put the chances as “not high”. Both remarks were reported by The Block, which organised the forum with The Hill.
The two men spoke in separate interviews, and they parted on what comes next. Moreno thinks the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) can deliver most of the bill by writing rules. Hill answers that a rule is not a statute and can be fought in court.
That disagreement matters more than the forecast. The bill expires with this Congress on 3 January 2027, and Democrats take both chambers the same day. Until a new text passes, what the two agencies write is the US rulebook for crypto markets.
What Hill and Moreno said about the CLARITY Act in the lame duck
Hill left the door open a crack. “We never give up hope in a lame duck, but it is lame, and therefore the chances are not high,” he said, in the fuller version of the quote given by Bitcoin Magazine. The same outlet has him adding: “I regret that it was not something we could get done effectively in this Congress.”
Moreno, whom Bitcoin Magazine describes as the bill’s lead sponsor in the Senate, was blunter. Besides the double zero, the magazine has him telling the forum there is “no scenario” in which crypto legislation passes the Senate during the lame-duck session, and links to a post from The Hill for the remark.
He blamed the clock and the drafting. “Time kills all deals,” he said, according to The Block, and: “The bill started at 300 pages, ended up at 600 pages.” In the outlet’s account, he said the talks had been “tornadoed” by disputes over President Donald Trump and ethics rules, and that he would consider restarting from the text the House passed.
On one point they agree: Congress should not have split its crypto agenda in two. The GENIUS Act, the stablecoin law, was signed in July 2025 while market structure was left for later. “To have GENIUS but not market structure is a huge mistake,” Hill said. The Block reports that he had urged the Senate and the administration last summer to move the two together.
The vote record: 60 votes were needed, 49 came
The bill is H.R. 3633. It would divide oversight of crypto markets between the SEC and the CFTC. The two roll calls that define its position are public.
| Date | Step | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 17 July 2025 | House vote on passage (roll call 199) | Passed 294-134 |
| 15 September 2026 | Senate cloture on the motion to proceed (vote 234, three fifths required) | Rejected 49-50 |
| 19 November 2026 | Hill and Moreno at the Capitol Crypto Forum | Moreno: “Zero. Zero.” Hill: chances “not high” |
| 3 January 2027 | End of the 119th Congress | Pending bills expire |
In the House, the Clerk’s record shows 216 Republicans and 78 Democrats in favour and 134 Democrats against. Hill leans on that figure of 78, Bitcoin Magazine notes, when he argues the subject is not a partisan one.
The Senate is where it stopped. The Senate roll call of 15 September lists the 50 no votes: 44 Democrats, the two independents who sit with them, and four Republicans, Susan Collins, Josh Hawley, Jerry Moran and Thom Tillis. One Democrat, Chris Coons, did not vote. The motion needed 60.
Tillis entered a motion to reconsider, Bitcoin Magazine reports, which keeps the option of another vote alive. It does not move the count. Eleven more senators would have to vote yes, and Democrats objected in September that the ethics provisions did not go far enough on Trump’s potential conflicts of interest in crypto, the magazine writes.
Time is the other limit. Government funding, the annual defence bill and the farm bill come first, the magazine writes, citing The Hill, and the lame-duck session is set to end in less than a month. A bill that has not passed both chambers when a Congress ends has to be introduced again in the next one and go back through committee.

From January, Democrats hold the gavels
The next Congress changes who decides. Coindaro explained on 6 November why Elizabeth Warren is expected to chair Senate Banking and why the lame duck was already a long shot. Thursday’s remarks put the same odds on the record, in the words of the bill’s leading Republicans.
In the House the majority party takes the chairs, so Hill stands to lose his. Maxine Waters is the committee’s top Democrat, and he found something to work with there. According to The Block, he took it as a good sign that Waters had named digital asset market structure among the issues she would take up as chair; Bitcoin Magazine says she did so in a memo to House Democrats.
What her version would look like is known only through reporting. Bitcoin Magazine relays the journalist Eleanor Terrett, who cites three industry sources in contact with Democratic staff: House Democrats are discussing turning Waters’ Crypto Investor and Consumer Bill of Rights into a market-structure bill, with a larger role for the SEC and a smaller one for the CFTC. Republicans have called it a “messaging bill”, the magazine adds. No such text has been published.
Hill intends to keep pushing from the minority. TokenPost reports that he framed the work as three bills: CLARITY, GENIUS and the PARITY Act on the tax treatment of digital assets, a bipartisan bill introduced in May 2026. Representative Steven Horsford, a Nevada Democrat, called them a “three-legged stool”, according to the same report.
Can the SEC and CFTC write 80% of it by rule?
Moreno’s answer is yes, with a condition. “I think it can accomplish 80% through a very rigorous rulemaking process that can’t be unwound,” he said, according to The Block. He wants the two agencies to spend the next two years writing rules that a later administration would find hard to reverse. He did not present this as the better route: “I think the right way to do it is Congress should pass the Clarity Act.”
Hill does not think rules can be made that solid. “It is subject to litigation. It does not have the force of law,” he said of agency action. The Block reports him saying that regulators have mostly followed the goals of the market-structure proposals, but that their authority is limited. He made the same case in October on Fox Business, where Decrypt quoted him: “In my judgement, these regulatory policies fall short of what we have to do, which is have a legislative solution.”

The record of the past two months gives each of them material. Much of what US crypto firms now rely on comes from the agencies, and little of it is a finished rule.
Bitcoin Magazine cites the SEC’s exemption for tokenized stocks as a case of regulators moving ahead on their own. The capital charges brokers apply to bitcoin, ether and stablecoins come from SEC staff answers which, by their own wording, have no legal force. The SEC’s proposed rule on brokers’ crypto holdings has been under White House review since 3 November, and its text has not been published. At the CFTC, the plan for retail crypto trading is an advance notice of proposed rulemaking, the step before a proposed rule, with comments due on 14 December.
Each of these instruments is easier to undo than a law. A commission can amend or repeal a rule adopted by its predecessors, and an exemption or a staff answer can be withdrawn by the agency that gave it. A statute stays until Congress changes it.
Hill’s litigation point already has a live example. On 3 November Judge Valerie Caproni, of the federal court in Manhattan, refused to halt trading in US stock perpetual futures, yet found the trade group suing the CFTC “likely to succeed on the merits” of its claim that the agency had no authority to approve them. That finding is preliminary, made on an emergency request. Our report on the stock perpetuals lawsuit against the CFTC follows the case.
Stablecoins are the exception, because there a law exists. The GENIUS Act applies from 18 January 2027, and even so the Treasury is still writing its rules: six senators asked it this week for a grace period for state-licensed issuers.
What the two interviews leave open
The two reports are selections from longer interviews, and the quotes above are the ones those outlets printed. On procedure, Bitcoin Magazine says only that Tillis’s motion keeps another vote possible. It gives no date for one.
Moreno’s 80% is his own estimate. The Block’s account does not say which parts of the bill fall in the remaining 20%, or how a rule would be made proof against a later commission.
The calendar is short. Comments on the CFTC’s crypto notice close on 14 December. The 119th Congress ends on 3 January 2027, taking H.R. 3633 with it unless the Senate acts first, and the GENIUS Act applies fifteen days later.
