Christine Lagarde used her last keynote at the Frankfurt European Banking Congress, on Friday 20 November 2026, to tell Europe’s lawmakers that the tokenisation of securities will not produce a single European market unless they write common rules for it. The central bank has built the settlement leg, the president of the European Central Bank (ECB) said in the speech, titled “Acting in time”. The rest is not hers to decide: “Common rules will be needed too, and those lie with legislators.”
The passage is short. Tokenisation takes up five short paragraphs of a speech about why Europe acts late on slow-moving problems, from capital markets to defence spending and computing power for artificial intelligence. Lagarde announced no measure and no timetable for tokenised markets, and named no bill. What she gave is a warning about timing, backed by one figure and by two pieces of ECB infrastructure, Pontes and Appia.
What Lagarde said about tokenisation, and what she left out
Lagarde presented wholesale markets, and tokenisation within them, as the second of three areas where the ECB chose to invest early, after retail payments and before the international role of the euro. Her definition is brief. With blockchain technology, she said, securities can be tokenised “so that they are issued, traded and settled on a single platform”. With the right framework, that is a chance to build a single market in digital assets that is integrated from the start, which she called “a huge opportunity” for Europe.
Then the limit. The market for tokenised assets was worth about €23 billion worldwide in March 2026, five times its size a year earlier, according to the speech. A footnote gives the origin and the scope of that number: a speech by ECB Executive Board member Piero Cipollone on 26 August, counting tokenised traditional assets recorded on public blockchains. It is a narrow measure, and it should not be compared with broader counts of tokenised assets.
A market that small is still setting its habits. If those develop separately, Lagarde said, “the market could split into platforms that follow different rules and cannot settle with one another”. She drew the lesson from Europe’s existing capital markets: “once standards and practices have diverged, they are very hard to bring back together.”
Several things are absent from the text. The speech does not contain the word stablecoin. It does not name the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) or the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA), and it does not mention a savings and investments union or a “28th regime” for companies. It says nothing about bitcoin, ether or any crypto asset. Lagarde spoke about bonds and other securities issued by institutions, and about the plumbing that settles them.
It was also a farewell. “This is the eighth time I have spoken here as President of the ECB, and it will sadly be the last,” she said. The ECB announced on 29 October that Lagarde will step down on 7 February 2027, before the end of her term.
Pontes: the part that already works
The built part is called Pontes. The Eurosystem, meaning the ECB and the national central banks of the euro area, launched it on 21 September 2026, in the words of the ECB press release of that day. Pontes lets wholesale transactions in tokenised assets be paid for in central bank money, the safest form of settlement cash, which banks hold in accounts at the central bank. It is not open to the public.
The ECB said an initial group had finished onboarding at launch: 13 market participants, among them Deutsche Bank, Santander, Société Générale, the European Investment Bank, KfW, DZ Bank and NRW.BANK, and four operators of distributed ledger platforms (Axiology, Cashlink, Clearstream and SWIAT). The Deutsche Bundesbank joined as a participant too. That group could start using Pontes at once, the ECB said, and more participants were due to connect in the following months.
What runs today is therefore a first version. The release says Pontes “will initially offer a core set of services”, with longer operating hours and added features introduced gradually and “full implementation expected by 2028”. National central banks label the same stage differently: Banca d’Italia’s page on the project calls 21 September “the initial launch of the Pilot phase” and puts the go-live of Pontes in 2028. Both descriptions cover the same facts: real transactions settle in central bank money now, through a limited service and a limited group of users.
Lagarde’s claim for Pontes is specific. “Every platform now has access to a common settlement asset,” she said, so that liquidity no longer has to be divided between platforms. That solves the cash side of a trade. It does not make two platforms use the same token formats, the same legal terms or the same rulebook.

A €1 billion bond from the euro area’s rescue fund
Her example was the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), the euro area’s rescue fund, which “settled a €1 billion digitally native bond on Pontes” earlier this month, in her words. A Bundesbank release dated 26 October describes the deal: the ESM priced its first digital benchmark bond, the Bundesbank acted as issuing and paying agent, and Clearstream, part of Deutsche Börse Group, created the bond on its D7 platform. The cash leg was to be settled through Pontes in T2, the Eurosystem’s existing system for large payments. DZ BANK and Société Générale advised.
The release calls it the first digital bond issue by a European supranational issuer to be settled through Pontes and says the deal marks the move of Europe’s wholesale digital infrastructure “from pilot projects to live deployment”. It gives no settlement day. The bond is also built to live in the traditional system: it is expected to be listed on the Luxembourg Stock Exchange, to be eligible as collateral with the Eurosystem and to be able to settle through TARGET2-Securities, the service that handles conventional bonds.
A German state bank on public Ethereum
A second deal went further on the technology. NRW.BANK, the development bank of the German state of North Rhine-Westphalia, said in a press release on 17 November that it had issued a bond on the public Ethereum blockchain, that DZ BANK had bought it, and that the payment was made through Pontes directly in central bank money. The issue used Germany’s electronic securities law (eWpG) and a smart contract written by DZ BANK that handles issuance, interest and redemption. The whole transaction took less than an hour, the bank said, where a conventional issue can take several days.
NRW.BANK has not disclosed the size of the bond, its maturity or the day it was issued. The two deals also show how far apart “tokenised” can be: one bond on a platform run by a market operator and bridged back to the traditional system, the other on a public chain where the smart contract, a program that runs on the chain, carries the bond’s rules.
Appia and the 2028 blueprint: still a plan
The second ECB project is Appia, and it has delivered no infrastructure yet. “Through Appia, we are working with market participants towards an integrated European market, including common standards,” Lagarde said, without a date. The date is in the September press release: Appia involves experiments and analysis by the Eurosystem, Danmarks Nationalbank and public and private stakeholders, “with the goal of delivering a blueprint by 2028”.
A blueprint is a set of findings and recommendations, not a network. What shape the market should take is itself unsettled, as the 127 replies to the ECB’s Appia consultation showed: respondents backed central bank money as the anchor and split over how many ledgers Europe should have.
| Piece | Status on 21 November 2026 | Who decides |
|---|---|---|
| Pontes (settlement of tokenised trades in central bank money) | In use since 21 September 2026 by an initial group, with a core set of services (a pilot phase, in Banca d’Italia’s wording); full implementation expected by 2028 | Eurosystem |
| ESM digital bond, €1 billion | Priced, per the Bundesbank release of 26 October; settled on Pontes earlier in November, per Lagarde; settlement day not published | ESM, with the Bundesbank and Clearstream |
| NRW.BANK bond on public Ethereum | Issued and paid through Pontes, per the bank’s release of 17 November; size, maturity and issue day not disclosed | NRW.BANK and DZ BANK, under German law |
| Appia (integrated market, common standards) | Analysis and experiments; blueprint due by 2028 | Eurosystem, with Danmarks Nationalbank and market participants |
| Common rules for tokenised markets | No text named in the speech | EU legislators |
| Supervision of capital markets (market integration package) | Council agreed the key elements of its position on 9 October; talks with Parliament not yet started as of that date | Council and European Parliament |
| Digital euro regulation | Parliament confirmed on 9 July 2026 the decision to open negotiations; the ECB aims for a first issuance in 2029 if the law is adopted this year | Council and European Parliament |
The rules are for the Council and Parliament to write
“But infrastructure alone is not enough,” Lagarde said, before handing the matter to legislators. She did not say which rules she means. One live file is close to the subject, and she commented on it elsewhere in the speech.
In December 2025 the European Commission proposed a market integration and supervision package. According to a note published on 9 October by the law firm Norton Rose Fulbright, it amends the regulation that set up ESMA, the rules on trading venues and securities depositories, the EU’s pilot regime for market infrastructure based on distributed ledgers, and MiCA. EU finance ministers agreed the key elements of the Council’s negotiating position on 9 October 2026. Under that position, the note says, ESMA would directly supervise significant clearing houses and securities depositories and the most significant cross-border trading venues. On crypto, only the most significant service providers would move to ESMA, where the Commission had proposed all of them. The board of supervisors, where national authorities sit, would remain ESMA’s main decision-making body.
Lagarde welcomed the agreement and criticised its content in the same breath. The Council’s position, she said, “weakens the European supervisor’s ability to take effective decisions and includes too many carve-outs”. That matches the line the central bank took days earlier, when the ECB’s stability review repeated its call for ESMA to supervise all EU crypto firms. The Council and Parliament can only start negotiating once Parliament has adopted its own position, the Norton Rose Fulbright note says.
The digital euro, the first of Lagarde’s three areas, is a separate law with its own clock. “If the legislation is adopted by the end of this year, we aim to be ready for a first issuance in 2029,” she said. The European Parliament’s Legislative Observatory shows that the economic affairs committee voted on 23 June 2026 and that the full house confirmed on 9 July the decision to open negotiations with the Council. The file is still listed as awaiting Parliament’s first-reading position. The ECB has already warned that a law later than the end of the year could push the launch back.

The Fed made a similar case three days earlier
The ECB is not alone in tying tokenised markets to central bank money. On 17 November, Federal Reserve governor Christopher Waller made a parallel case in the United States, also without announcing a rule or a date.
What remains open after the speech
The speech leaves several points unanswered. Lagarde did not say whether “common rules” means the package already on the table, a change to the EU’s pilot regime for distributed ledgers or a new text. Neither the ESM nor the Bundesbank release states the day the €1 billion bond settled, and NRW.BANK has not published the size of its issue.
The calendar is clearer. The end of 2026 is the ECB’s target for the digital euro law. Lagarde leaves on 7 February 2027 and her successor has to be appointed by the European Council. Pontes is due to be fully implemented by 2028, the year the Appia blueprint is expected.

1 comment