Market cap $2.19 T −3.65 % over 24 hours24h volume $73.68 BBTC dominance 58.1 %ETH 10.0 %Fear & Greed 10 Extreme fearCoins 21,490

ECB stability review restates its call for ESMA to supervise all EU crypto firms; Council and Parliament want a narrower plan

The ECB stability review repeats its call for ESMA to supervise all EU crypto firms and to end MiCA's bank-deposit floor. Council and Parliament want less.

13 min read

Abstract city skyline with a signed document, a vault door and a calendar
Table of contents
  1. Two short passages in a 141-page review
  2. ESMA supervision of crypto firms: all of them, with tighter rules for the biggest
    1. What a “significant CASP” would be
  3. Council and Parliament want ESMA for the largest firms only
  4. Stablecoin reserves: liquidity floors in place of the bank-deposit rule
    1. The numbers the central banks proposed in September
  5. No interest on stablecoins, and no yield by the back door
  6. Who would feel the changes
  7. 1 December, then negotiations on two separate tracks

The European Central Bank used its Financial Stability Review, published on Wednesday 18 November 2026, to repeat two demands on the EU crypto rulebook. It wants ESMA supervision of crypto firms to cover every provider in the Union, with the European Securities and Markets Authority taking over from national authorities. And it says the MiCA rule that makes stablecoin issuers keep a fixed share of their reserves in bank deposits could be dropped in favour of liquidity floors.

The review is the ECB’s twice-yearly risk report, not a legal act, and neither position is new. The supervision stance comes from a formal opinion the bank adopted on 9 April 2026. The reserves idea comes from a paper the European System of Central Banks (ESCB) sent to the European Commission in September.

What has changed since April is the direction of the lawmakers. The Council agreed on 9 October that only the largest cross-border crypto firms would move to ESMA, and the draft before the European Parliament says much the same. The central bank is still defending the Commission’s original, wider plan.

Two short passages in a 141-page review

Crypto takes up little room in this edition, whose headline risks are artificial intelligence valuations, public finances and geoeconomic tensions. The word stablecoin appears in one paragraph only.

That paragraph closes the banking chapter (page 78). The bank welcomes the Commission’s intention to review MiCA, which it calls MiCAR, and then says it “considers that the minimum deposit requirements for stablecoins could be removed and replaced with minimum liquidity requirements for reserve assets”. Issuers would get more flexibility and still be able to meet redemption requests promptly, the review says, and there would be fewer channels for contagion between banks and stablecoins. A footnote adds that the new requirements would need careful calibration because of possible “second-order effects”.

The second passage closes the chapter on non-banks (page 98). It deals with the Commission’s market integration and supervision package, known as MISP, published on 4 December 2025. There the bank supports the proposal “to transfer the authorisation, monitoring and enforcement powers for all CASPs to ESMA”. CASP is the legal term for crypto-asset service providers: exchanges, brokers, custodians and similar firms.

ESMA supervision of crypto firms: all of them, with tighter rules for the biggest

Under MiCA as it applies today, a crypto firm asks for its licence in one member state. The national authority there grants it and supervises the firm, and the licence then lets the firm serve clients in all the others.

The Commission proposal, a regulation that amends MiCA and 13 other laws, would end that arrangement. Authorisation, day-to-day monitoring and sanctions would all sit with ESMA, the EU markets authority based in Paris. In its opinion of 9 April 2026 (CON/2026/13), signed by President Christine Lagarde and published in the Official Journal on 28 May, the ECB said it “fully supports” the package, which it called an “ambitious step” towards integrated capital markets. On crypto firms it welcomed the transfer of powers for all providers, saying this would bring supervisors into line, reduce fragmentation and limit cross-border risks.

The opinion gives a banking reason too. Banks increasingly offer crypto services and hold client money that crypto firms deposit with them, and some crypto groups bundle custody, trading and settlement across borders largely outside consolidated supervision. A shock in such a group can reach a bank. For the ECB, that argues for one supervisor at EU level.

What a “significant CASP” would be

MiCA already has a category of significant providers, but it does little. Article 85 of the regulation sets the bar at 15 million active users in the Union, averaged over a calendar year, and the ESCB paper notes that firms above it face no specific requirements as a result.

The central bank wants to keep the label and give it weight. The review repeats the April request: wider criteria built on objective measures such as size, cross-border activity, systemic relevance, trading volumes on platforms, volumes exchanged against funds and the activity of the whole group. Firms that qualify “should be subject to tighter prudential requirements”.

The opinion lists what that would mean. A significant provider would have to set up an intermediate parent company inside the EU and keep a group-level recovery plan. It would need stronger internal controls, sound pay policies, prior supervisory approval for directors and senior managers, and fuller reporting at company and group level. For crypto firms in general, the ECB asks for own-funds requirements that reflect the risks a firm takes; the current ones rest on fixed minimums and a share of fixed overheads, the ESCB paper notes.

ESMA got conditions too. The opinion calls it indispensable that the authority has “sufficient staffing and funding”, and backs a carefully sequenced handover from national supervisors, with transition plans and staggered timelines. The ECB also asked for a non-voting seat on ESMA’s new executive board whenever crypto firms are discussed, because those firms hold and exchange stablecoins, which touch payment systems and monetary policy.

Abstract scales beside a bank building, a shield, a globe and a document
The ECB wants ESMA to authorise and supervise every crypto firm in the EU, with tighter prudential rules for the largest.

Council and Parliament want ESMA for the largest firms only

On scope, the ECB is at odds with both co-legislators. EU finance ministers agreed the key elements of the Council’s negotiating position on 9 October 2026, and the Council press release is plain about crypto: only the most significant cross-border providers would become immediately subject to ESMA supervision. “This replaces the blanket regime for all such providers as proposed by the Commission,” it says.

The Council text also provides a two-year transition, during which ESMA-led teams of EU and national experts would prepare the transfer, and creates a full-time ESMA executive board with a chair and five independent members.

Parliament has not fixed its position. Its economic and monetary affairs committee (ECON) is scheduled to vote on 1 December 2026, according to a 22 October note from the law firm Norton Rose Fulbright. Parliament’s own Legislative Observatory lists the file as “awaiting committee decision” and shows no vote date. The firm names Markus Ferber of the centre-right EPP and Eero Heinäluoma of the Socialists and Democrats as the rapporteurs; the Observatory has Ferber in charge of the regulation that amends MiCA.

Their draft compromise, as the firm describes it, limits ESMA supervision to significant providers, defined through a new Article 59a of MiCA, and lets smaller firms opt in. ESMA would become the only enforcer of MiCA’s market abuse rules for every provider, whatever its size. The firm notes the amendments can still change.

That leaves the Commission and the ECB on one side and the two institutions that write the law on the other. The review says there should be “no carve-outs” in the criteria that identify systemic players across the package, and that talks will now turn on those criteria. If only significant crypto firms go to ESMA, the definition of significant decides almost everything, which is why the ECB wants group-wide activity counted.

Parliament and the Council asked for the ECB opinion, but it does not bind them. Member states have set out positions of their own, including France’s call for ESMA to supervise more crypto firms.

Stablecoin reserves: liquidity floors in place of the bank-deposit rule

The reserves proposal is a separate file and touches a different group of companies: the issuers of euro and dollar tokens authorised in the EU. MiCA sorts stablecoins into e-money tokens, which track one official currency, and asset-referenced tokens, which track anything else.

The deposit floor sits in several articles. For asset-referenced tokens, Article 36(4) has the European Banking Authority (EBA) set the minimum held as deposits at credit institutions, which cannot be lower than 30% of the amount referenced in each official currency, and Article 45(7) raises that to 60% for significant tokens. For e-money tokens issued by e-money institutions, Article 54 requires at least 30% of the funds received to be kept in separate bank accounts, and Article 58 puts significant tokens under the stricter regime. The ESCB response to the Commission’s MiCA consultation sums the rule up as at least 30% of reserve assets in bank deposits, 60% for significant tokens, with the rest in low-risk, highly liquid instruments.

Deposits were chosen because they can be withdrawn fast when holders ask for their money back. The central banks now see two problems. The rule ties issuers directly to banks, so a run on a token forces the issuer to pull deposits quickly, which can leave a bank short of funding. It also works in reverse: the paper cites March 2023, when trouble at Silicon Valley Bank set off a run on USDC because Circle, the issuer, held part of the reserves there.

The second problem is income. Sight deposits pay little. The paper puts the average yield on corporate deposits at 0.53% in April 2026, using ECB statistics, and says issuers need adequate profits if a competitive market for euro-denominated stablecoins is to emerge.

The numbers the central banks proposed in September

The ESCB would delete the deposit percentages and write minimum “liquidity buckets” into Article 36(4): shares of the reserve that must mature within one working day and within five. As a minimum starting point, subject to further analysis, it takes the figures from draft technical standards already prepared by the EBA.

RequirementNon-significant tokenSignificant token
MiCA today: minimum share of reserves in bank deposits (ESCB summary)30%60%
ESCB proposal: minimum share in bank depositsNoneNone
ESCB proposal: assets maturing within one working dayAt least 20%At least 40%
ESCB proposal: assets maturing within five working days (includes the daily share)At least 30%At least 60%

Overnight reverse repos and short-term government bills are the alternatives to deposits the paper names. The reserves outside the two buckets would still have to be highly liquid and could face maturity limits. Tokens pegged to EU currencies might also be treated differently from those pegged to foreign ones, because the supply of safe, liquid assets differs from one currency to another.

The loosening has limits. The ESCB wants issuers to spread their reserves across more counterparties, with lower concentration limits for significant tokens, and floats an overall cap on how much deposit funding a bank may take from stablecoin issuers. The EBA draft standards already contain such limits: no more than 25% of a reserve with any one systemically important bank, 15% with other large banks, 5% with the rest, and no deposit above 1.5% of the receiving bank’s total assets.

Those standards were not yet in force when the ESCB wrote, since the Commission had still to approve them. Until they are, the paper says, “the deposit requirement currently acts as the only liquidity floor”. The central banks ask for them to be adopted quickly, whatever happens to the deposit rule later.

Abstract coin stacks with a bar chart, pie chart, hourglass and padlock
Daily and weekly liquidity floors would replace the fixed share of stablecoin reserves held in bank deposits.

No interest on stablecoins, and no yield by the back door

On one point the central banks want MiCA tightened. Articles 40 and 50 bar issuers and service providers from granting interest on asset-referenced and e-money tokens, and count any benefit tied to how long a holder keeps the token as interest. The ESCB wants the ban kept and widened.

Its target is indirect pay. The paper says the prohibition should also cover services that MiCA does not regulate, such as crypto lending, borrowing and staking, through which some platforms reproduce the effect of interest. It names tri-party schemes, some loyalty programme benefits and the liquidity blockchain and earns a reward, which makes rewriting history very expensive.">mining incentives built into DeFi protocols as ways around the rule. Keeping and strengthening the ban on direct and indirect remuneration “should be a clear legislative priority”, it says.

The reasoning is that an e-money token is electronic money and that issuing it is not deposit-taking. If lawmakers follow, holders in the EU should expect fewer reward schemes on euro or dollar tokens kept with a regulated platform. Our guide to yield-bearing stablecoins and the rules on interest explains where the line runs today.

The right to cash out would not change: the ESCB recommends keeping holders’ unconditional right to redeem, with no minimum amount. The same paper says MiCA has no legal basis for stablecoins issued jointly with an entity outside the Union, so allowing them would take an amendment, and it defends banks’ ability to issue e-money tokens from their own balance sheet without a compulsory subsidiary.

Who would feel the changes

For exchanges, brokers and custodians, the question is who signs the licence. Under the Commission and ECB line it is ESMA for everyone. Under the Council position and the Parliament draft, only the largest cross-border groups would move, and the others would stay with their home supervisor unless they chose ESMA. In both cases the biggest platforms would face heavier rules if the ECB’s ideas on capital and group structure are taken up.

Issuers of euro and dollar tokens would gain room in how they invest reserves, and swap a single deposit percentage for daily and weekly maturity tests. Banks that hold those reserves would lose part of a funding source the ESCB describes as less stable than retail deposits. Holders would notice little day to day: redemption at par stays, and so does the interest ban. An ECB survey published last week found that one in 20 euro area consumers holds a stablecoin, mostly dollar tokens.

More may follow. The review lists “additional measures to address financial stability concerns about stablecoin issuance” among the open MiCA issues, and the April opinion said there was evidence of services being provided in the EU on stablecoins not authorised under MiCA, including algorithmic ones.

1 December, then negotiations on two separate tracks

Supervision will be settled first. Once Parliament has adopted its position, talks with the Council can begin. The Council said in October that it wants a “timely agreement” in line with the EU’s “One Europe, One Market” agenda, which leaders want carried out in 2026 where possible and by the end of 2027 at the latest. Neither institution has published a date for a final deal.

The reserve rule moves more slowly. Changing it means amending MiCA outside the supervision package, and the Commission has so far only consulted. Article 140 of MiCA gives the Commission until 30 June 2027 to report to Parliament and the Council on how the regulation is applied, with a legislative proposal attached where appropriate. Industry replies to the consultation, such as the Cardano Foundation’s rejection of new DeFi and staking rules, show how contested that review will be.

Our explainer on what MiCA means for crypto users in the EU covers the regulation itself. The ECB’s next Financial Stability Review is due on 26 May 2027.

Sources

  1. ECB Financial Stability Review, November 2026 (PDF), 18 November 2026 ecb.europa.eu
  2. ESCB response to the European Commission's targeted consultation on MiCAR, September 2026 (PDF) ecb.europa.eu
  3. Opinion of the European Central Bank of 9 April 2026 (CON/2026/13), OJ C/2026/2837, 28 May 2026 eur-lex.europa.eu
  4. Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA), EUR-Lex eur-lex.europa.eu
  5. Council of the EU press release: Council agrees key elements of measures to deepen EU capital markets, 9 October 2026 consilium.europa.eu
  6. Norton Rose Fulbright, Regulation Tomorrow: European Parliament progresses negotiations on MISP package, 22 October 2026 regulationtomorrow.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *