Market cap $2.18 T −2.74 % over 24 hours24h volume $75.31 BBTC dominance 59.1 %ETH 10.1 %Fear & Greed 12 Extreme fearCoins 21,839

Supreme Court turns away Custodia Bank’s Fed master account case, ending a six-year fight with no ruling on the law

The Supreme Court denied Custodia Bank's petition on 16 November 2026. The Fed keeps its say over master accounts; its payment account is not final.

14 min read

Abstract gavel in front of a bank building with a closed padlock
Table of contents
  1. What the Supreme Court did on 16 November
  2. Master account explained: the Fed access a crypto bank cannot buy elsewhere
  3. The legal question: does “shall” oblige the Fed to open the account?
  4. Six years from application to the final denial
  5. What a denial of certiorari means, and what it does not
  6. The fight moves to the Fed’s skinny master account
    1. What the proposed payment account would and would not give
  7. What is still open, and the dates to watch

The US Supreme Court refused on Monday 16 November 2026 to hear Custodia Bank’s case for a Federal Reserve master account, closing the last court open to the Wyoming crypto bank six years after it first applied. The Court’s order list for the day places No. 26-62, Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, among the petitions it denied, and the case docket now ends with two words: “Petition DENIED”. The list notes no dissent from any justice in the case. As is usual for such orders, the Court gave no reasons.

The refusal leaves in place a ruling of the US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, dated 31 October 2025, that a regional Federal Reserve Bank may turn down an account request even from a bank that is legally eligible for one. The justices did not approve that reading of the law. They declined to review it, and a refusal to review settles nothing for a crypto bank that asks for the same access outside the Tenth Circuit.

Custodia, founded and run by Caitlin Long, asked the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City for a master account in 2020 and was refused in January 2023. The Block, which reported the denial at 17:15 UTC on Monday, said the bank did not immediately answer its request for comment.

The court route is shut at a moment when the Fed itself has opened a narrower one. In March the Kansas City Fed, the same Reserve Bank that rejected Custodia, approved a limited account for Kraken Financial. In May the Fed’s Board of Governors proposed a restricted “payment account”, often called a skinny master account, for institutions of this kind. The Board had published no final version as of 16 November 2026.

What the Supreme Court did on 16 November

Custodia had asked the Court for a writ of certiorari, the order by which the justices agree to review a lower court’s decision. The Court receives thousands of these petitions each term and takes a small share of them. By its long-standing practice, four of the nine justices must vote to grant one.

The docket shows how the request moved. Justice Neil Gorsuch gave Custodia extra time on 29 May 2026, pushing the filing deadline to 11 July. The petition arrived on 10 July. Three briefs from outside supporters followed on 12 and 13 August. The Federal Reserve Board, represented by Solicitor General D. John Sauer, and the Kansas City Fed, represented by the law firm King & Spalding, filed their oppositions on 13 October after two extensions. Custodia replied on 28 October, the same day the case was distributed for the justices’ private conference of Friday 13 November. The denial came on the next order list, three days later.

Several other denials in Monday’s list come with written dissents or a note that a justice would have taken the case. Custodia’s line has neither.

Master account explained: the Fed access a crypto bank cannot buy elsewhere

A master account is an account that a bank holds at one of the 12 regional Federal Reserve Banks. It is the door to the Fed’s payment services, such as the Fedwire system used for large dollar transfers, and it lets a bank settle payments in central bank money, the reserves described in our guide to how banks create money. A firm without one has to send its dollars through a partner bank that does have an account.

That dependence is the crypto industry’s complaint. In its brief supporting Custodia, the trade group The Digital Chamber wrote that a denial “forces a financial institution to rely on private intermediaries whose services can be withdrawn at will”, as quoted by Banking Dive on 14 August.

Custodia was built for this purpose. According to its petition to the Supreme Court, the bank is headquartered in Cheyenne, mainly serves digital asset companies, and holds a Wyoming charter as a special purpose depository institution (SPDI), a category the state created by law in 2019. The charter lets it provide payment services and run a banking business that makes no loans. It is a state bank, but it is not a member of the Federal Reserve System, and the Board separately rejected its application for membership.

The whole case turned on a few words in two federal statutes. Custodia’s petition put the question this way: whether the Monetary Control Act, which says the Federal Reserve “shall” provide its services to legally eligible nonmember depository institutions, leaves the presidents of the regional Reserve Banks any discretion to deny master accounts to such institutions.

Custodia’s answer was no. If Congress wrote that the services shall be available to eligible nonmember banks, then an eligible bank is entitled to the account that gives access to them. Its lawyer at the Supreme Court was Kannon Shanmugam of Davis Polk & Wardwell.

The Fed’s answer, which every court accepted, rests on another provision. Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act says Reserve Banks “may” receive deposits. The district court read that as permission, not obligation: Reserve Banks may open accounts, it said, not that they shall. The Tenth Circuit agreed and held that the “shall” sentence in the Monetary Control Act is about the pricing of Fed services, not about who gets an account. In its brief opposing review, filed on 13 October, the Kansas City Fed framed the only question as whether the law gives every eligible institution an “absolute entitlement” to an account.

The Kansas City Fed gave the justices further reasons to stay out. No two courts of appeals disagree on the point, it said, and it described Custodia as conceding as much. It also called the case a poor vehicle, because Custodia had dropped its claim against the Reserve Bank under the Administrative Procedure Act and had not challenged the reasons given for the denial. Custodia had argued that only the Tenth Circuit has held that Reserve Bank presidents may deny an account, with a Second Circuit decision of 2026 concerning the closing of an existing account and a Ninth Circuit case on hold.

Abstract scales of justice beside a document, a bank building and a key
The case turned on whether the word "shall" in federal law obliges a Reserve Bank to open an account.

Custodia had three briefs behind it, all quoted by Banking Dive. The Blockchain Association argued that the appeals court ruling gives the Fed “veto power over chartering judgments by state regulators”. Senator Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming and former Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania, both Republicans, filed together, and their target was the use the courts had made of the Toomey Amendment.

That provision, passed in the defence bill of December 2022 and now 12 U.S.C. 248c, creates no right to an account. It orders the Board to keep a public, searchable database of every institution that holds a master account or has asked for one, showing whether each request was approved, rejected, pending or withdrawn. The Tenth Circuit turned the word “rejected” against Custodia: in the Kansas City Fed’s account of the ruling, the list shows that Congress expected Reserve Banks to refuse some eligible applicants. The two lawmakers answered that the amendment is a disclosure rule, one that “confers no statutory authority and prescribes no criteria for master-account approval or rejection.”

Six years from application to the final denial

Custodia applied to the Kansas City Fed in 2020, the court record says. Long marked the fifth anniversary of the charter and of the application in a LinkedIn post that Banking Dive quoted on 5 November 2025.

What happened next is told differently by each side. Custodia’s petition says the Kansas City Fed told it early on that it was “legally eligible” and that there were “no showstoppers”, and that staff memos rated its capital adequate and its liquidity risk low. The application then sat. In June 2022, after 19 months without a decision, Custodia sued the Board and the Kansas City Fed in federal court in Wyoming.

The refusal came in January 2023. The Kansas City Fed president’s letter, as quoted in the petition, cited “concerns with business models that are concentrated in crypto-asset-related activities or have concentrated exposures to the crypto-asset sector”. The Kansas City Fed’s own brief adds what the letter also said: that Custodia’s “unprecedented business model” depended on “higher-risk business activities”, that the bank sat outside the capital framework applied by federal bank regulators, and that the review had found risks in its anti-money-laundering and sanctions compliance, its financial viability and its counterparties.

On 29 March 2024, US District Judge Scott Skavdahl ruled for the Fed without a trial. Custodia appealed. A three-judge panel of the Tenth Circuit upheld the ruling by two votes to one on 31 October 2025. “We conclude the plain language of the relevant statutes grants Federal Reserve Banks discretion to reject master account access requests from eligible entities,” Judge David Ebel wrote for the majority in the court’s opinion.

Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented. “By claiming unreviewable discretion over access to the nation’s financial system, the Fed has gone too far,” he wrote. Custodia called his dissent “the next best thing” to a win, in a statement quoted by Banking Dive, and asked the full court to rehear the case. It refused on 13 March 2026, by seven votes to three according to Banking Dive. Tymkovich dissented again, noting, the outlet reported, that Reserve Banks began issuing master accounts in 1998 and first denied one in 2015.

DateStepResult
2020Custodia applies to the Kansas City Fed for a master accountPending for more than two years
June 2022Custodia sues in the US District Court for WyomingCase No. 22-125
January 2023Kansas City Fed decides on the applicationDenied
29 March 2024District court, Judge Scott SkavdahlSummary judgment for the Fed
31 October 2025Tenth Circuit panel, No. 24-8024Fed wins 2-1, Tymkovich dissents
13 March 2026Tenth Circuit, request for rehearing by the full courtRefused 7-3
10 July 2026Petition for certiorari, No. 26-62Filed at the Supreme Court
13 October 2026Board and Kansas City Fed briefsBoth oppose review
16 November 2026Supreme Court order listPetition denied

What a denial of certiorari means, and what it does not

A denial of certiorari is not a judgment on who was right. The Supreme Court has not said that the Federal Reserve Act lets Reserve Banks refuse eligible banks, and Monday’s order creates no precedent for the country.

What it does is make the Tenth Circuit’s decision final for Custodia. That decision is binding law in the six states of the circuit: Wyoming, Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Utah. Wyoming is the state whose SPDI charter was written for crypto banks, and it lies in the district of the Kansas City Fed, which decided both Custodia’s request and Kraken Financial’s.

Elsewhere the question is formally open. Another court of appeals could still read the statutes differently in another bank’s case, and a real disagreement between circuits is the kind of conflict the Supreme Court tends to take up. Today, though, the two sides agree on one fact: no court of appeals has ever held that an eligible institution is entitled to a master account.

For Custodia, the practical choices are the ones Banking Dive listed when the rehearing was refused in March. It can keep working through a correspondent bank, or it can file a new request under the Fed’s newer and narrower framework.

The fight moves to the Fed’s skinny master account

That framework did not exist when Custodia applied. Fed Governor Christopher Waller floated a “skinny” master account in October 2025, an account with payment access and little else. He set its limits himself. “They can request,” he said in remarks quoted by Banking Dive. “It doesn’t mean you get one, let’s be clear.” The Board asked for public input on a prototype on 19 December 2025.

On 4 March 2026 the Kansas City Fed announced that it had approved a limited purpose account for Payward Financial, which does business as Kraken Financial and holds the same kind of Wyoming SPDI charter as Custodia. The Reserve Bank classed it in Tier 3 of the Board’s account access guidelines, the tier for institutions that are neither federally insured nor under federal prudential supervision. The account runs for an initial term of one year, with what the release calls “restrictions and limitations tailored for Kraken Financial’s business model and risk profile”. The Kansas City Fed does not publish those restrictions. Kraken Financial is the bank of the group behind the Kraken exchange, whose latest figures are in our report on Payward’s third quarter.

Abstract hourglass and calendar next to a vault door and a handshake
Kraken Financial's limited account was approved on 4 March 2026 for an initial term of one year.

The rules took shape on 20 May 2026, when the Board asked for comment on a formal “payment account” proposal, published in the Federal Register on 26 May under docket OP-1878. Comments closed on 27 July. The Board said by way of reminder that requests for accounts are decided by the Reserve Banks, and that the proposal changes nothing about who is legally eligible.

What the proposed payment account would and would not give

The account in the proposal is built to clear and settle the holder’s own payments. The notice gives the holder four services, those with automated controls against overdrafts: the Fedwire Funds Service, the FedNow instant payment service, the National Settlement Service and the Fedwire Securities Service, the last for transfers free of payment only. The table shows what is withheld.

FeatureProposed payment account (20 May 2026)
Interest on balancesNone
Discount window borrowingNot available
Intraday credit (overdrafts)Not available; automated controls block overdrafts
FedACHNot included
Acting as a correspondent bank for othersNot allowed
End-of-day balanceLimit set for each holder from its expected payment flows, never above $1 billion
Time to decide a requestGenerally 90 calendar days; 45 for federally insured institutions

The first line of that table is where Custodia and the Fed parted ways at the Supreme Court. The Kansas City Fed told the justices that the proposed account could even make Custodia’s claims moot, and that Custodia had indicated in the lower courts that a limited payment account would satisfy it. Custodia answered that a limited-purpose account was not enough, partly because its closing balance would earn no interest, according to The Block, which cited Bloomberg.

A charter from Washington does not settle the matter either. The national trust banks that the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency has approved this autumn, described in our pieces on Coinbase’s trust bank approval and Ripple’s trust bank charter, take no deposits, and an OCC charter is not a Fed account. In the Tenth Circuit, the courts have left access to the Fed’s payment system to the Reserve Banks’ decision.

What is still open, and the dates to watch

The first date is 31 December 2026. In the May notice the Board encouraged Reserve Banks to pause decisions on requests from Tier 3 institutions until it finishes its work on the payment account, and wrote that the pause is expected to end on or before that day. Custodia holds the same Wyoming charter as Kraken Financial, which the Kansas City Fed placed in that tier. Whether the Board publishes a final version before the year ends, and with which limits, will define what a bank like Custodia can now ask for.

The second falls in March 2027, a year after the Kansas City Fed announced Kraken Financial’s account with its initial one-year term. The release does not say what happens after that.

Whether Custodia will apply for a payment account once the rules are final is not known. And the legal question itself is not dead: a similar dispute is waiting in the Ninth Circuit, where a case brought by PayServices was on hold as of a status report of 22 June 2026, according to Custodia’s petition. If a court there or elsewhere sides with the applicant, the Supreme Court could be asked the same question again, this time with two appeals courts in disagreement.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 26-62, Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors (petition, briefs in opposition, order of 16 November 2026) supremecourt.gov
  2. US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, No. 24-8024, opinion of 31 October 2025 (CourtListener) courtlistener.com
  3. Federal Register, proposed revisions to the Payment System Risk policy and account access guidelines (Payment Accounts), docket OP-1878, 26 May 2026 federalregister.gov
  4. Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City approves limited account, 4 March 2026 kansascityfed.org
  5. Banking Dive, Custodia loses at the Tenth Circuit, 5 November 2025 bankingdive.com
  6. The Block, Supreme Court rejects Custodia Bank's bid for a Fed master account, 16 November 2026 theblock.co

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *