Market cap $2.19 T −3.65 % over 24 hours24h volume $73.68 BBTC dominance 58.1 %ETH 10.0 %Fear & Greed 10 Extreme fearCoins 21,490

S&P keeps USDT at its lowest stability score as Tether’s risky assets reach 28%, and Tether answers with The Big Short

Tether S&P rating: USDT stays at 5 (weak) as gold, bitcoin, loans and equities reach 28% of supply. Tether blames S&P's method. The numbers, line by line.

11 min read

Abstract coin beside a warning sign and an hourglass on a dark background
Table of contents
  1. What S&P counts as high-risk, and how the 28% splits
  2. The buffer is $7.95 billion; bitcoin alone is $8.37 billion
  3. Why 5 is the floor: the weaknesses S&P could not score
    1. El Salvador’s 70% rule and the missing segregation
    2. An audit nobody outside can read
    3. Redeeming at Tether starts at $100,000
  4. Tether S&P rating history: from 4 to 5 in three years
  5. What Tether says, and what the statement leaves out
  6. What it changes for a USDT holder
  7. What would move the score, and the next dates

S&P Global Ratings kept Tether’s USDT at 5, the “weak” bottom rung of its stablecoin stability scale, in a six-page report dated Wednesday 18 November 2026. The score has not moved since the agency cut it from 4 in November 2025. What has moved is the number behind it: the assets S&P treats as high-risk now equal 28% of the USDT in circulation at 30 September, against 24% a year earlier.

So this Tether S&P rating is a reaffirmation, not a second downgrade, and the report says why it could not be one. S&P lists further weaknesses in governance, regulation and redemption, then adds that it makes no adjustment because its assessment “cannot be lower than 5”.

Tether rejected the finding in a statement to Cointelegraph: “The problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves.” The company pointed to the agency’s own record and to The Big Short, the film about the 2008 mortgage crisis. S&P notes on the first page that the report was produced neither at the issuer’s request nor with its input.

What S&P counts as high-risk, and how the 28% splits

S&P works from the same document as everyone else: Tether’s reserve report for 30 September 2026, attested by BDO, with $191.5 billion of assets behind $183.5 billion of USDT. The agency expresses each asset class as a share of the tokens in circulation, which is why its percentages add up to about 104% and not 100%. That extra 4.3% is the buffer, up slightly from 3.9% a year before.

Inside the 28%, the report gives three lines. Gold rose to about $19 billion, or 10% of USDT in circulation, from $12.9 billion (7%). Bitcoin fell to $8.4 billion (5%) from $9.9 billion (6%). Public equities are new: $4.2 billion, or 2%. S&P gives no figure for the rest, which it describes as secured loans, corporate bonds and other investments with limited disclosure. By subtraction that remainder is about 11%, and the BDO report’s own lines for those three items add up to $20.2 billion, which is 11% of $183.5 billion.

Reserve asset at 30 September 2026Share of USDT in circulation (S&P)Amount
US Treasury bills, under 90 days67%$122.8B (BDO report)
Overnight reverse repos backed by Treasury bills5%$9.5B (BDO report)
Other reverse repos and non-US Treasury bills4%about $7.2B (BDO report)
Cash and bank depositsunder 0.5%under $0.1B
Gold10%about $19B (S&P), $19.08B (BDO report)
Bitcoin5%$8.4B (S&P), $8.37B (BDO report)
Public equities2%$4.2B
Secured loans, corporate bonds, other investmentsabout 11% (28% minus the three lines above)$20.2B (sum of three BDO report lines)
All high-risk assets28%about $51.9B (sum of the BDO report lines)

The low-risk part shrank a little. Treasury bills and the overnight repos backed by them stood at 72% in S&P’s count, down from 75% at the previous review, although the combined holding now exceeds $130 billion, which by the agency’s reckoning puts Tether among the largest holders of such paper anywhere. The agency’s complaint on that side is about names: the reports do not identify custodians, counterparties or the banks that hold the accounts.

Abstract pie chart beside gold bars, a coin, a magnifying glass and scales
Gold, bitcoin, equities, loans and bonds add up to 28% of USDT in circulation in S&P's count.

The buffer is $7.95 billion; bitcoin alone is $8.37 billion

S&P’s central sentence is that a significant fall in the value of these assets could leave USDT undercollateralized, and in the governance section it writes that the share of higher-risk assets has grown over twelve months and is far larger than the reserve buffer. S&P publishes no ratio of that kind. The table below is plain arithmetic on the 30 September figures in the BDO report, the same figures as in our account of the third-quarter attestation.

Measure at 30 September 2026FigureAgainst the $7.95B buffer
Bitcoin$8.37B1.05 times the buffer
Gold$19.08B2.4 times
Bitcoin plus gold$27.45B3.5 times; a 29% fall in both would equal the buffer
All assets S&P calls high-riskabout $51.9B6.5 times; a fall of about 15% across all of them would equal the buffer

Those are sensitivities at one date, 30 September. They are not a forecast, a reserve marked lower is not a token off its peg, and they ignore what Tether earns: the company reported $1.5 billion of net operating profit for the third quarter alone.

Still, the two prices have moved since the report’s date. The report values bitcoin at $83,621. Bitcoin traded near $63,280 around 05:42 UTC on Thursday 19 November in Coindaro’s market data, about 24% lower. Applied to the $8.37 billion Tether reported, that is roughly $2.0 billion less. Gold was marked at $4,157 an ounce; Kitco’s spot bid was $3,738.60 at 05:52 UTC on 19 November, about 10% lower, a day after gold slipped below $3,800. Applied to the $19.08 billion gold line, that is about $1.9 billion less.

Added together, the two come to about $4.0 billion, close to half of the September buffer. This is arithmetic on 30 September holdings and 19 November prices, and it assumes Tether has neither bought nor sold bitcoin or gold since, which the company has not said. Three more things are missing from the sum and could move it either way: the profit earned since 1 October, the value of the loans and equities, and any change in the amount of USDT outstanding. Only the next reserve report, for 31 December, will give the real figure.

Why 5 is the floor: the weaknesses S&P could not score

The method has two steps. First comes an asset assessment from 1 (very strong) to 5 (weak). Then the agency looks at governance, the legal and regulatory framework, redemption and liquidity, technology and the track record, and may lower the result. For USDT the asset step already gives 5, so the second step is marked neutral, with a note that it would otherwise have counted.

El Salvador’s 70% rule and the missing segregation

Tether moved from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador in 2025 and is supervised there by the National Commission of Digital Assets (CNAD). Its rules ask for one-to-one backing and for at least 70% of reserves in assets that can be sold within 30 days. S&P calls that test broad, because loans, bitcoin and gold can qualify, and notes that nothing in it obliges an issuer to keep reserve assets apart from its own, as US and European rules do.

The agency calls the move to a supervised regime a positive step. It adds that no public information shows whether USDT’s reserves are segregated, or how far they are protected if the issuer failed or if one of Tether’s other businesses lost money. Those businesses have multiplied: four divisions since 2024 (finance, data, power, education), investments in artificial intelligence and bitcoin blockchain and earns a reward, which makes rewriting history very expensive.">mining, and a stake of more than 10% in Juventus Football Club, followed by an all-cash offer for control that the main shareholder turned down.

An audit nobody outside can read

On disclosure, S&P lists four gaps. Tether publishes no policy on which assets may enter the reserves or on what it would do if one of them fell sharply. Its attestations are quarterly, when other stablecoins generally report monthly. The figures it posts on its website between reports are not reviewed by the auditor and carry no asset breakdown. And the first full audit, the 2025 accounts on which KPMG US reportedly gave an unqualified opinion, has not been published: neither the statements, nor the notes, nor the auditor’s report.

Redeeming at Tether starts at $100,000

Direct redemption is open only to holders with a verified account, which costs $150 to open, for amounts of at least $100,000 and against a fee of 0.1% or $1,000, whichever is higher, according to the report. Everyone else sells on an exchange. S&P considers that secondary market deep enough to offset part of the problem, with one limit: redemptions depend on banking hours.

The track record is the strong line of the report. USDT, launched in October 2014, showed only minor fluctuations after the Terra and FTX failures of 2022, held its price during the Silicon Valley Bank episode of March 2023, when some rivals slipped, and has been especially steady over the past twelve months, S&P writes. Its capitalization grew from about $158 billion to about $184 billion in the year to 30 September 2026.

Abstract document and shield beside a bank building and a bar chart
S&P's other weaknesses concern disclosure, segregation of reserves and direct redemption.

Tether S&P rating history: from 4 to 5 in three years

DateS&P assessment of USDTHigh-risk share cited
December 20234 (constrained), first assessmentnot comparable
3 December 20244 (constrained), per S&P’s report of that date17% at 30 September 2024 (as reported by The Block)
26 November 2025cut to 5 (weak)24% at 30 September 2025 (S&P)
18 November 20265 (weak), unchanged28% at 30 September 2026 (S&P)

When S&P cut the score a year ago, The Block reported that bitcoin stood at about 5.6% of USDT in circulation against a buffer of about 3.9%, and that the high-risk share had been 17% a year before. Chief executive Paolo Ardoino answered on X at the time that the company took the agency’s dislike as a point of pride, according to the same report. Twelve months on the bitcoin share is lower and the buffer a little higher, yet the whole high-risk group has grown by four points, through gold and the new equity holdings.

USDT is not alone at the bottom. S&P’s list of assessments shows TrueUSD at 5 (11 November 2026) and Ethena’s USDe at 5 (January 2026). Circle’s USDC is at 2, “strong”, since its review of December 2025, as is Global Dollar (USDG); USDS/DAI and First Digital USD sit at 4. Our guide to the differences between USDT and USDC explains how the two reserve models diverge.

What Tether says, and what the statement leaves out

Tether’s answer, as carried by Cointelegraph, attacks the method. Rating agencies gave top grades to mortgage securities that failed in 2008, which is the story The Big Short tells, and the company argues that this history is the real weakness. The statement quoted by the outlet does not dispute the 28%, the absence of segregation rules or the unpublished audit. As of Thursday morning Tether had posted nothing about the report on its news page, where the latest items are investments announced on 16 and 17 November.

The company’s case rests on results: the reserves exceeded liabilities by $7.95 billion at the last count, and S&P itself concedes the price record. The agency’s case rests on what cannot be checked from outside. Its report does not claim that USDT is short of assets: it describes the token as fully backed at 30 September.

What it changes for a USDT holder

Nothing changes in the token itself. A stability assessment is an opinion on the capacity to hold a peg; S&P states on every page that it is not a rating action. In Europe the question of access is older and separate: Coinbase was due to convert the USDT of its retail customers in the European Economic Area at the end of October, as we described when USDC overtook USDT in euro trading.

DefiLlama showed USDT at $0.9989 and $175.07 billion in circulation at 05:54 UTC on 19 November, against $175.21 billion a day earlier and $182.95 billion a month earlier, a fall of 4.3% over the month. Nearly all of that decline predates the report and belongs to the wider contraction of stablecoin supply since October. DefiLlama counts tokens on public chains and its total is not the liability figure of the attestation, so the two should not be subtracted from each other.

One mechanical point follows from that shrinkage. Redemptions are paid from cash and Treasury bills. If supply falls and the gold, bitcoin, loans and equities stay where they are, their share of what remains rises without any new purchase. Tether has published no asset breakdown since the one for 30 September.

What would move the score, and the next dates

S&P says the assessment could improve if the exposure to high-risk assets falls, on the assumption that Tether also discloses more about the composition and valuation of its assets and about the creditworthiness of its custodians, counterparties and banks. It cannot go lower.

The next checkpoint is the reserve report for 31 December 2026; the September one was published on 30 October, a month after the quarter closed. It will value bitcoin and gold at their prices on that day. Publication of the audited 2025 statements would answer one of the gaps S&P lists. Tether has given no date for it.

Sources

  1. S&P Global Ratings: Stablecoin Stability Assessment, Tether (USDT), 18 November 2026 spglobal.com
  2. S&P Global Ratings: list of stablecoin stability assessments spglobal.com
  3. Cointelegraph: Tether's statement on the S&P assessment, 18 November 2026 cointelegraph.com
  4. BDO assurance report and Tether Financial Figures and Reserves Report, as of 30 September 2026 assets.ctfassets.net
  5. The Block: S&P cuts USDT stability score to weak, 26 November 2025 theblock.co
  6. DefiLlama: stablecoin circulating supply, read on 19 November 2026 at 05:54 UTC defillama.com
  7. Kitco: live spot gold bid, read on 19 November 2026 at 05:52 UTC kitco.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *