A federal judge in New York acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, known as the MEV brothers, on Monday 16 November 2026 of every charge in what she called a “first of its kind” prosecution over MEV, the profit made from ordering transactions inside an Ethereum block. In a 46-page opinion and order, Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke of the Southern District of New York granted the brothers’ motion for a judgment of acquittal on wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, a year after their jury failed to reach a verdict. The case concerned about $25 million taken from sandwich-trading bots in twelve seconds on 2 April 2023.
The MEV brothers were acquitted for one reason: the judge found that prosecutors never showed a lie. Wire fraud needs a material misrepresentation, and none of the government’s theories supplied one, she wrote. “The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” the opinion says on its first page.
The ruling does not say that exploiting a relay bug is lawful, and it does not say that code is the only rule on a blockchain. It says that, on the evidence of this trial, no reasonable jury could find the false statement that the federal fraud statute requires.
Why the MEV brothers were acquitted: three theories, no false statement
Under Rule 29 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, a court must enter an acquittal when the evidence is too thin for any reasonable jury to convict, even with every inference drawn in the government’s favour. The brothers had asked for it at the close of the prosecution’s case and again after the mistrial. Judge Clarke decided the motion on the government’s own evidence and added that the rest of the trial confirmed the result.
The opinion describes the prosecution’s account of the deception as “a moving target”. Before trial the government listed seven alleged misrepresentations; in its post-trial brief it named six. The judge reduced them to three features of the operation, which the brothers called Omakase: the lure transactions, the “false signature” and the failure to behave as what prosecutors called an honest MEV-Boost validator.
The lure transactions promised nothing
Prosecutors argued that the eight bait trades placed in Ethereum’s public mempool falsely signalled a profitable opportunity and an intention to trade. The judge answered that a pending transaction makes no promise to be sandwiched, to be bundled or to land at a given place in a block. On the idea that a trader would agree to be sandwiched, she wrote that “no trader would ever make such a promise”. The bait trades were also never withdrawn: they were published in another block within a minute, a fact neither side disputed.
That is why the comparison with spoofing, where a trader posts orders he means to cancel, did not hold. “The analogy to spoofing fails on Ethereum,” the judge wrote, because the lure trades executed and because they were not placed on a regulated market whose rules forbid that conduct. The government pointed to MEV-Boost’s published specifications as rules. The court read them as a description of how the software works, with no terms of use, and noted that the government’s main witness testified the brothers were not even running MEV-Boost that day.
The signature fooled no one, because the relay never checked
The second theory concerned the block header the brothers’ validator signed with two fields, the parent root and the state root, set to zero. According to the trial testimony summarised in the opinion, a signature means the validator will propose that block or be slashed, meaning it loses part of its stake. The validator signed with its real address and was slashed 1 ETH. The court saw an accurate statement there.
It was not material either. The Ultrasound relay did not look at those two fields before revealing the block’s contents, so the zeros changed nothing in its behaviour. “Defendants’ alleged falsity had no effect on the behavior of the relay,” the opinion says. The government called no witness from Ultrasound and no expert on Ethereum.
Breaking a design is not the same as lying
The third theory was that the brothers posed as an honest validator inside a system built on separating block builders from block proposers. The judge found no statement in registering a validator, asking a relay for a header or proposing a different block, since Ethereum lets a validator order transactions as it likes and the separation of roles is not part of the protocol. Omakase “may have frustrated the spirit” of MEV-Boost’s design, she wrote, but frustrating a design is not fraud.
Nor could the scheme taken as a whole fill the gap. The government, the opinion says, “is asking the Court to find evidence of a material misrepresentation without identifying one”. Evidence that the brothers hid their plan and their identities went to intent, which is a separate element. Once the wire fraud counts were gone, the judge held, the money laundering conspiracy charge could not stand either.

What happened on 2 April 2023, according to the trial record
Few of the facts were disputed at trial, the opinion says. The brothers went after one kind of trader. A sandwich bot watches the mempool for a large pending wallet senza affidare la custodia dei fondi a una società.">swap, buys the same token just before it, lets the victim buy at the inflated price and sells just after. Our guide to how MEV, front-running and sandwiches work walks through the arithmetic. The sandwich only pays if the three trades execute in that exact order, so bots send them as an all-or-nothing bundle to a block builder.
MEV-Boost, software released by Flashbots in 2022, is the pipe those bundles travel through. Builders assemble blocks, relays pass them to the validator whose turn it is, and the validator picks the most profitable block from a header alone, without seeing the transactions inside. Only after it signs the header does the relay reveal the contents. The sequence is known as commit and reveal; it is explained in our guide to block builders and sandwich protection.
According to the opinion, the brothers and two employees wrote the code over several months, registered sixteen validators and tested their bait dozens of times. The lures were built to attract bots trading large amounts. On 2 April 2023, when one of their validators was due to propose a block, they sent eight lure transactions, each tailored to a specific bot. The bots bundled all eight. The validator asked the Ultrasound relay for the header, signed it with the two fields set to zero, and the relay handed over the full block. At the time, relay code checked who had signed, not whether those fields were correct.
Now able to see trades the bots believed private, the validator built a second block. It kept the bots’ buy orders and replaced each lure with a sale of the same token, which sank the price before the bots’ closing sale. It then proposed both blocks. The network rejected the first, which was invalid on purpose, and accepted the second. Three sandwich traders lost about $25 million between them.
So the people the indictment called victims were themselves running a strategy that, in the judge’s words, is “controversial” and leaves ordinary traders with a worse price and no recourse. The court drew no legal conclusion from that.
Flashbots changed the relay code within 24 hours so that a header is checked before a block is revealed, the opinion says. A wallet holding $3 million of the proceeds was frozen, and by October 2023 the brothers had cashed out the rest, moving it through their company’s Coinbase account in hundreds of transactions.
From arrest to acquittal in two and a half years
The chronology below follows the opinion and the public docket on CourtListener.
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| 2 April 2023 | Omakase runs in one twelve-second block slot; about $25 million taken from three sandwich traders |
| 8 May 2024 | Three-count indictment: wire fraud conspiracy, wire fraud, money laundering conspiracy |
| 14 October 2025 | The trial opens; it lasts nearly four weeks |
| 7 November 2025 | Mistrial after three days of deliberations without a verdict |
| 12 December 2025 | Joint defence motion for acquittal or, alternatively, dismissal of the superseding indictment |
| 2 January 2026 | The judge lets the DeFi Education Fund file an amicus brief over the government’s objection |
| 13 March 2026 | Oral argument on the motion, first set for 26 February and then for 23 March |
| 2 April 2026 | The judge tells both sides to be ready for a retrial on 7 June 2027 |
| 16 November 2026 | Acquittal on all counts; the clerk is directed to close the case |
A fourth charge, conspiracy to receive stolen property, appeared in a superseding indictment and was dropped by the government before trial. The judge had earlier refused to dismiss the fraud counts, because the indictment alleged that the signature and the lures carried implied promises. The trial was where those allegations had to be proved. They were not, in her reading of the record.
Three days after the mistrial, in a letter of 10 November 2025, prosecutors asked for a new trial in late February or early March 2026, or failing that from 20 April 2026, the first date Anton Peraire-Bueno’s lawyers could offer. The defence replied that no date was needed yet. The judge heard the acquittal motion first. On 2 April 2026, three weeks after the argument, she told both sides to be prepared to start a retrial on 7 June 2027.
The acquittal came seven months before that date. A status conference planned for 2 September 2026 was adjourned with no new date. On 9 November, a week before the ruling, the judge let the brothers trade listed securities and exercise stock options from their jobs, changes to their bail that the government did not oppose.
Two crypto policy groups weighed in along the way. Coin Center sought leave to file a brief during the trial, on 31 October 2025. The DeFi Education Fund followed on 19 December; prosecutors objected on 30 December that its brief “merely recites legal arguments already rejected by this Court”, and the judge admitted it anyway. Peter Van Valkenburgh, Coin Center’s executive director, called the acquittal “excellent news”, Cointelegraph reported on 17 November. Under the prosecutors’ theory, he told the outlet, anyone taking part in an open network would have had to wonder whether their behaviour might later be declared dishonest.
The Mango Markets precedent, and a code argument that failed elsewhere
Judge Clarke leaned on United States v. Eisenberg, the 2025 decision in which Judge Arun Subramanian, of the same court, acquitted the Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg of wire fraud after a jury had convicted him. Eisenberg had borrowed and withdrawn more than $100 million against collateral whose price he had pushed up. There were no terms of service forbidding it and no promise in the borrow transactions, that court found; other users’ expectations were not enough. Judge Clarke applied the same reasoning to the sandwich traders who expected their bundles to execute as planned.
Prosecutors appealed the Eisenberg acquittal, DL News reported on 7 January 2026: in a filing dated 22 December 2025 they wrote that the judge’s view of the facts “would unsettle traditional understandings of fraud”. No outcome of that appeal has been reported since. A second judge in the same district has now followed the reasoning it attacks.
In the Peraire-Bueno case itself, the docket showed no notice of appeal on 17 November; its last entry was the opinion, filed the day before. Neither Cointelegraph nor CryptoSlate reported a comment from the US Attorney’s office or from the defence.
The decision should not be read as a general win for “code is law” defences. It turns on one element of one statute and on gaps in one trial record. Other courts facing other charges have gone the other way: in October, Israel’s top court rejected the argument that the code allowed the Nomad bridge withdrawals and cleared a suspect’s extradition to the United States. The opinion also leaves room for future prosecutors. It recalls that a misrepresentation need not be a spoken false statement and that half-truths can qualify, and it records that the government had given up any theory based on omissions in this case.
One footnote goes further than the holding. The judge declined to decide whether the indictment violated the brothers’ due process rights, a challenge they had built on the novelty of the case, but wrote that “this prosecution raises serious due process concerns”.
What the ruling changes for bots, validators and ordinary traders
For searchers and validators, the practical reading is narrow. Sending bait into the mempool, signing a header and taking the slashing penalty, or proposing a block other than the one a relay supplied were not, on this record, statements capable of being false. The court said nothing about civil claims, about other criminal statutes or about how the same acts would be treated on a venue with binding rules. Its spoofing discussion suggests that explicit rules change the analysis, because a rule can turn a silent act into an implied promise.

That point reaches beyond Ethereum’s open mempool. CryptoSlate noted on 17 November that the SEC’s order of 17 September 2026 on tokenized-stock venues makes each venue describe its MEV policies, or state that it has none, and keeps the securities antifraud rules in force. One of those venues, OKXICE, plans to open tokenized stock trading on 23 November.
For someone swapping tokens on a decentralised exchange, nothing in the ruling reduces the risk of being sandwiched. The opinion states plainly that the victim of a sandwich gets a worse price and has no recourse. Protection remains a matter of settings and routing, covered in our guide to making a swap safely.
Still open after the acquittal
The government has not said publicly whether it will try to challenge the acquittal, and the opinion does not address the $3 million frozen in 2023.
The other unknown is Eisenberg, the decision this one rests on. If the appeals court restores a broader reading of falsity there, the next MEV prosecution would start from different ground.
